Kolahi Jafar, Soolari Ahmad
Torabinejad Research Center, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
Quintessence Int. 2006 Sep;37(8):605-12.
The purpose of this study was to discuss the concept of delaying the use of chlorhexidine mouthrinse (CHX) until some time after the use of dentifrice.
Sources included 13 electronic databases, 7 international drug reference books, and the World Wide Web; references of all relevant papers; and further information requested from authors and organizations. Inclusion criteria were a predefined hierarchy of evidence. Study validity was assessed with checklists. Two reviewers independently screened sources, extracted data, and assessed validity.
CHX, a cation, interacts and forms salts of low solubility and antibacterial activity with anions, such as sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) and sodium monofluorophosphate (MFP). CHX and MFP are not compatible in clinically relevant concentrations in vitro. A 30-minute interval between SLS and CHX rinsing gave a significantly reduced antiplaque effect of CHX, whereas after 2 hours the neutralizing effect of SLS disappeared. Rinsing with dentifrice slurry and CHX produced a significantly increased plaque score compared to CHX and water. In regard to tooth staining by CHX mouthrinses, use of dentifrice before CHX showed a reduction in staining of 18%, whereas CHX followed by dentifrice showed a reduction in staining of about 79%. Literature relating to this interaction is limited; more controlled microbiologic and clinical studies are needed to certify the inaccuracy of this modality of administration.
To optimize the antiplaque effect of CHX, it seems best that the interval between toothbrushing and rinsing with CHX be more than 30 minutes, cautiously close to 2 hours after brushing.
本研究旨在探讨将洗必泰漱口水(CHX)的使用推迟至使用牙膏一段时间之后的概念。
资料来源包括13个电子数据库、7本国际药物参考书以及万维网;所有相关论文的参考文献;并向作者和组织索要了更多信息。纳入标准为预先定义的证据等级。使用清单评估研究的有效性。两名审阅者独立筛选资料来源、提取数据并评估有效性。
CHX作为一种阳离子,可与阴离子(如十二烷基硫酸钠(SLS)和单氟磷酸钠(MFP))相互作用并形成低溶解度和抗菌活性的盐。CHX和MFP在体外临床相关浓度下不相容。SLS和CHX冲洗之间间隔30分钟会使CHX的抗牙菌斑效果显著降低,而2小时后SLS的中和作用消失。与CHX和水相比,用牙膏糊剂和CHX冲洗会使牙菌斑评分显著增加。关于CHX漱口水导致牙齿染色,在CHX之前使用牙膏可使染色减少18%,而先使用CHX再使用牙膏可使染色减少约79%。有关这种相互作用的文献有限;需要更多对照的微生物学和临床研究来证实这种给药方式的不准确性。
为优化CHX的抗牙菌斑效果,似乎最好在刷牙和用CHX冲洗之间的间隔超过30分钟,谨慎地接近刷牙后2小时。