Roach M, Leidholdt E M, Tatera B S, Joseph J
Radiation-Oncology Service, Martinez VA Medical Center, CA 94553.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1990 Jun;18(6):1449-54. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(90)90321-a.
Between October 1987 and November 1988, 19 endobronchial Iridium-192 line source placements were attempted in 17 patients with advanced incurable lung cancer. Approximately 30 Gy was delivered to the endobronchus using a low dose rate (LDR) afterloading technique delivering a mean dose of 70 cGy/hr at 5 mm. Improvement in subjective symptoms was noted in 67% of evaluable patients whereas objective responses defined by chest X ray and bronchoscopy were noted in 26% and 60%, respectively. No significant morbidity was observed. The radiation exposure to health care workers was low ranging from 10 to 40 mRem per treatment course with most of the staff receiving less than 10 mRem per treatment course (minimal detectable level 10 mRem). The results of this series are compared with selected series using low dose rate as well as intermediate dose rate (IDR) and high dose rate (HDR) endobronchial radiation therapy (EBRT). Based on bronchoscopic responses from the selected series reviewed, both HDR low total dose per treatment (range 7.5-10 Gy) and LDR high total dose per treatment (range 30-50 Gy) are effective in palliating the vast majority of patients with endobronchial lesions. Intermediate dose rate is also effective using fractions similar to high dose rate but total dose similar to low dose rate. The efficacy of endobronchial radiation therapy in the palliative setting suggest a possible role for endobronchial radiation therapy combined with external beam irradiation with or without chemotherapy in the initial management of localized lung cancer. Defining the optimal total dose, dose rate, and the exact role of endobronchial radiation therapy in the management of lung cancer will require large cooperative trials with standardization of techniques and definitions.
1987年10月至1988年11月期间,对17例晚期无法治愈的肺癌患者尝试进行了19次支气管内铱-192线源植入。使用低剂量率(LDR)后装技术向支气管内输送约30 Gy的剂量,在5 mm处的平均剂量率为70 cGy/小时。67%的可评估患者主观症状得到改善,而胸部X线和支气管镜检查确定的客观缓解率分别为26%和60%。未观察到明显的并发症。医护人员所受的辐射剂量较低,每个疗程为10至40 mRem,大多数工作人员每个疗程接受的辐射剂量低于10 mRem(最小可检测水平为10 mRem)。将该系列结果与使用低剂量率以及中剂量率(IDR)和高剂量率(HDR)支气管内放射治疗(EBRT)的选定系列进行了比较。根据所审查的选定系列的支气管镜检查反应,HDR每次治疗低总剂量(范围7.5 - 10 Gy)和LDR每次治疗高总剂量(范围30 - 50 Gy)在缓解绝大多数支气管内病变患者方面均有效。中剂量率使用与高剂量率相似的分次剂量但总剂量与低剂量率相似时也有效。支气管内放射治疗在姑息治疗中的疗效表明,支气管内放射治疗联合外照射放疗,无论是否联合化疗,在局限性肺癌的初始治疗中可能发挥作用。确定最佳总剂量、剂量率以及支气管内放射治疗在肺癌治疗中的确切作用将需要进行技术和定义标准化的大型合作试验。