Smeets Tamara, Brug J, de Vries H
Department of Health Education.romotion, Maastricht University, PO Box 616, 6200 MD Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Health Educ Res. 2008 Jun;23(3):402-13. doi: 10.1093/her/cyl101. Epub 2006 Oct 10.
Computer-tailored printed education can be a promising way of promoting physical activity. The present study tested whether computer-tailored feedback on physical activity is effective and whether there are differences between respondents with low and high motivation to change. Respondents (n = 487) were randomly assigned to a tailored intervention group or a no information control group. Physical activity and determinants were measured at baseline and after 3 months. At post-test, the motivated respondents in the control group were more likely not to meet the recommendation for physical activity than to meet it, and motivated respondents in the experimental group were more likely to engage in transport-related activities and showed more improvement over time for the total activity score than respondents in the control group (beta = 0.24, P = 0.02). Both groups improved their behaviour over time. No group differences in physical activity were found for the unmotivated respondents. The results showed that the effects of the tailored feedback were restricted to respondents who had a positive motivation to change at baseline. Possible explanations could be that unmotivated respondents were unwilling to read and process the information because they felt 'no need to change'. Alternatively, one tailored feedback letter may not have been sufficient for this unmotivated group.
计算机定制的印刷教育可能是促进体育活动的一种有前景的方式。本研究测试了关于体育活动的计算机定制反馈是否有效,以及在改变动机低和高的受访者之间是否存在差异。受访者(n = 487)被随机分配到定制干预组或无信息对照组。在基线和3个月后测量体育活动及相关决定因素。在测试后,对照组中有改变动机的受访者未达到体育活动建议的可能性高于达到建议的可能性,而实验组中有改变动机的受访者更有可能参与与交通相关的活动,并且随着时间推移,其总活动得分比对照组受访者有更大改善(β = 0.24,P = 0.02)。两组随着时间推移都改善了他们的行为。对于没有改变动机的受访者,未发现体育活动方面的组间差异。结果表明,定制反馈的效果仅限于在基线时有积极改变动机的受访者。可能的解释是,没有改变动机的受访者不愿意阅读和处理信息,因为他们觉得“没有改变的必要”。或者,一封定制反馈信对这个没有改变动机的群体可能是不够的。