Sassi Franco, Luft Harold S, Guadagnoli Edward
Department of Social Policy, The London School of Economics and Political Science, London, United Kingdom.
Am J Public Health. 2006 Dec;96(12):2165-72. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2005.071761. Epub 2006 Oct 31.
We assessed whether population rates of mammography screening, and their changes over time, were associated with improvements in breast cancer stage at diagnosis and whether the strength of this association varied by race/ethnicity.
We analyzed state cancer registry data linked to socioeconomic characteristics of patients' areas of residence for 1990-1998 time trends in the likelihood of early stage diagnosis. We appended each cancer registry record with matching subgroup estimates of self-reported mammography screening.
Trends in screening and stage at diagnosis were consistent within groups, but African American women had a significantly lower proportion of early stage cancers despite an advantage in screening. Population screening rates were significantly associated with early diagnosis, with a weaker association in African American women than White women (odds ratio [OR] = 1.70; P<.0001 vs OR=2.02; P<.0001, respectively).
Improvements in screening rates during the 1990s across racial/ethnic groups appear to have contributed significantly to earlier diagnosis within each group, but a smaller effect in African American women should raise concerns. A key health policy challenge is to ensure that screening effectively translates into earlier diagnosis.
我们评估了乳腺钼靶筛查的人群比率及其随时间的变化是否与乳腺癌诊断时分期的改善相关,以及这种关联的强度是否因种族/族裔而异。
我们分析了与患者居住地区社会经济特征相关的州癌症登记数据,以了解1990 - 1998年早期诊断可能性的时间趋势。我们为每个癌症登记记录附加了自我报告的乳腺钼靶筛查的匹配亚组估计值。
各群体内筛查和诊断分期的趋势一致,但尽管非裔美国女性在筛查方面具有优势,其早期癌症的比例仍显著较低。人群筛查率与早期诊断显著相关,非裔美国女性的关联强度低于白人女性(优势比[OR]分别为1.70;P <.0001和OR = 2.02;P <.0001)。
20世纪90年代各种族/族裔群体筛查率的提高似乎对每组内的早期诊断有显著贡献,但非裔美国女性的效果较小,应引起关注。一项关键的卫生政策挑战是确保筛查有效地转化为早期诊断。