Tapio I, Värv S, Bennewitz J, Maleviciute J, Fimland E, Grislis Z, Meuwissen T H E, Miceikiene I, Olsaker I, Viinalass H, Vilkki J, Kantanen J
Institute of Biotechnology and Food Research, MTT Agrifood Research Finland, FI-31600 Jokioinen, Finland.
Conserv Biol. 2006 Dec;20(6):1768-79. doi: 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2006.00488.x.
Northern European indigenous cattle breeds are currently endangered and at a risk of becoming extinct. We analyzed variation at 20 microsatellite loci in 23 indigenous, 3 old imported, and 9 modern commercial cattle breeds that are presently distributed in northern Europe. We measured the breeds' allelic richness and heterozygosity, and studied their genetic relationships with a neighbor-joining tree based on the Chord genetic distance matrix. We used the Weitzman approach and the core set diversity measure of Eding et al. (2002) to quantify the contribution of each breed to the maximum amount of genetic diversity and to identify breeds important for the conservation of genetic diversity. We defined 11 breeds as a "safe set" of breeds (not endangered) and estimated a reduction in genetic diversity if all nonsafe (endangered) breeds were lost. We then calculated the increase in genetic diversity by adding one by one each of the nonsafe breeds to the safe set (the safe-set-plus-one approach). The neighbor-joining tree grouped the northern European cattle breeds into Black-and-White type, Baltic Red, and Nordic cattle groups. Väne cattle, Bohus Poll, and Danish Jersey had the highest relative contribution to the maximum amount of genetic diversity when the diversity was quantified by the Weitzman diversity measure. These breeds not only showed phylogenetic distinctiveness but also low within-population variation. When the Eding et al. method was applied, Eastern Finncattle and Lithuanian White Backed cattle contributed most of the genetic variation. If the loss of the nonsafe set of breeds happens, the reduction in genetic diversity would be substantial (72%) based on the Weitzman approach, but relatively small (1.81%) based on the Eding et al. method. The safe set contained only 66% of the observed microsatellite alleles. The safe-set-plus-one approach indicated that Bohus Poll and Väne cattle contributed most to the Weitzman diversity, whereas the Eastern Finncattle contribution was the highest according to the Eding et al. method. Our results indicate that both methods of Weitzman and Eding et al. recognize the importance of local populations as a valuable resource of genetic variation.
北欧本土牛品种目前正濒临灭绝。我们分析了目前分布在北欧的23个本土牛品种、3个古老引进品种和9个现代商业牛品种中20个微卫星位点的变异情况。我们测量了这些品种的等位基因丰富度和杂合度,并基于Chord遗传距离矩阵用邻接法构建树状图来研究它们的遗传关系。我们采用韦茨曼方法以及埃丁等人(2002年)提出的核心集多样性度量方法,来量化每个品种对最大遗传多样性量的贡献,并确定对遗传多样性保护至关重要的品种。我们将11个品种定义为“安全品种集”(非濒危品种),并估计了如果所有非安全(濒危)品种都消失,遗传多样性将会减少的情况。然后,我们通过将每个非安全品种逐一添加到安全品种集中(即安全品种集加一法)来计算遗传多样性的增加情况。邻接法构建的树状图将北欧牛品种分为黑白花类型、波罗的海红牛和北欧牛组。当用韦茨曼多样性度量方法来量化多样性时,瓦内牛、博胡斯波耳牛和丹麦泽西牛对最大遗传多样性量的相对贡献最高。这些品种不仅显示出系统发育独特性,而且种群内变异程度较低。当应用埃丁等人的方法时,东芬兰牛和立陶宛白背牛贡献了大部分遗传变异。如果非安全品种集消失,基于韦茨曼方法,遗传多样性的减少幅度将很大(72%),但基于埃丁等人的方法则相对较小(1.81%)。安全品种集仅包含所观察到的微卫星等位基因的66%。安全品种集加一法表明,博胡斯波耳牛和瓦内牛对韦茨曼多样性的贡献最大,而根据埃丁等人的方法,东芬兰牛的贡献最高。我们的结果表明,韦茨曼方法和埃丁等人的方法都认识到当地种群作为遗传变异宝贵资源的重要性。