Smith W T, Tattersall M H, Irwig L M, Langlands A O
Department of Community Medicine, Westmead Hospital, NSW, Australia.
Eur J Cancer. 1991;27(11):1448-53. doi: 10.1016/0277-5379(91)90029-d.
The quality, quantity and balance of undergraduate cancer teaching in Australian Medical Schools were investigated by a survey, using a self-administered questionnaire, of recent graduates from all Australian medical schools. Stratified random cluster sampling was used and a response rate of 84% (389 respondents) was achieved. The results revealed substantial differences in knowledge, experience in, and rating of teaching between the medical, surgical, radiotherapeutic and palliative components of cancer management. The proportions of graduates who had never attended radiotherapy and palliative care clinics or units (42.3% and 49.9%, respectively) were more than double the proportion who had never attended medical and surgical cancer clinics or units (17.5% and 10.9%, respectively). More than twice as many graduates rated their instruction in the palliative management of cancer as poor or very poor (29.4%) compared with those rating their instruction as poor or very poor in both cancer prevention (8.4%) and treatment for cure (14.6%). The respondents displayed a considerable lack of knowledge about radiotherapy treatment options, and reported a lack of perceived competence in doing cervical smears. Their answers to questions about 5-year survival of selected cancers, about the existence of screening tests validly shown to reduce mortality, and the ages at which breast and cervical cancers are likely to develop all revealed worrying levels of incorrect knowledge. There was some important disturbing variation in levels of knowledge, experience and rating of cancer instruction between states and between universities.
通过对澳大利亚所有医学院校近期毕业生进行问卷调查,采用自填式问卷的方式,对澳大利亚医学院校本科癌症教学的质量、数量和平衡性进行了调查。采用分层随机整群抽样,获得了84%(389名受访者)的回复率。结果显示,在癌症管理的医学、外科、放射治疗和姑息治疗部分之间,在知识、经验和教学评分方面存在显著差异。从未参加过放疗和姑息治疗诊所或科室的毕业生比例(分别为42.3%和49.9%)是从未参加过癌症内科和外科诊所或科室的毕业生比例(分别为17.5%和10.9%)的两倍多。将癌症姑息治疗教学评为差或非常差的毕业生人数(29.4%)是将癌症预防(8.4%)和根治性治疗教学评为差或非常差的毕业生人数的两倍多。受访者对放疗治疗方案的知识相当匮乏,并且报告在进行宫颈涂片检查方面缺乏感知能力。他们对某些癌症5年生存率、有效降低死亡率的筛查测试的存在以及乳腺癌和宫颈癌可能发病年龄等问题的回答都显示出令人担忧的错误知识水平。各州之间以及各大学之间在癌症教学的知识、经验和评分水平上存在一些重要的令人不安的差异。