Mansberger Steven L, Johnson Chris A, Cioffi George A
Devers Eye Institute/Discoveries in Sight, Portland, OR 97210, USA.
J Glaucoma. 2007 Jan;16(1):73-80. doi: 10.1097/01.ijg.0000243481.75155.97.
To determine the effect of screening location on the frequency of abnormal test results with Frequency Doubling Technology (FDT) perimetry.
Retrospective cross-sectional study.
The Vision Screening Outreach Project conducted FDT testing in community sites surrounding Portland, Oregon. The sites were separated into a specific location type: health care clinics, work sites, senior centers, festivals/fairs, food banks/shelters, and other locations. These locations were compared for differences in the proportion of screening failures.
Screening failure (defined as a repeatable, abnormal FDT result in either eye).
There were 9052 participants from 211 locations in Oregon and Washington. On initial FDT testing, the right and left eye had abnormal results in 18% (1654/9052) and 21% (1918/9052) of participants. Of those with abnormal FDT results, approximately 30% of eyes reverted to normal on repeat testing. Overall, 13% of participants were screening failures. Screening failure was highly associated with age (P<0.001). After controlling for age, participants at senior centers (P<0.001) were most likely to be screening failures and participants at work sites (P=0.006) were least likely to be screening failures when compared with health clinics.
An investigator should repeat an initially abnormal FDT result when screening with FDT. Age and the location of testing influence the probability of a screening failure. Screening in senior centers is most likely to result in screening failure. However, only a randomized controlled trial can determine the true benefit of FDT screening in these locations.
确定筛查地点对使用倍频技术(FDT)视野检查异常检查结果频率的影响。
回顾性横断面研究。
视力筛查外展项目在俄勒冈州波特兰市周边的社区地点进行FDT测试。这些地点被分为特定的地点类型:医疗诊所、工作场所、老年中心、节日/集市、食品银行/收容所和其他地点。比较这些地点筛查失败比例的差异。
筛查失败(定义为任一眼睛出现可重复的异常FDT结果)。
来自俄勒冈州和华盛顿州211个地点的9052名参与者。在初次FDT测试中,右眼和左眼分别有18%(1654/9052)和21%(1918/9052)的参与者结果异常。在FDT结果异常的参与者中,约30%的眼睛在重复测试时恢复正常。总体而言,13%的参与者筛查失败。筛查失败与年龄高度相关(P<0.001)。在控制年龄后,与健康诊所相比,老年中心的参与者(P<0.001)最有可能筛查失败,工作场所的参与者(P=0.006)最不可能筛查失败。
使用FDT进行筛查时,研究者应重复最初异常的FDT结果。年龄和测试地点会影响筛查失败的概率。在老年中心进行筛查最有可能导致筛查失败。然而,只有随机对照试验才能确定在这些地点进行FDT筛查的真正益处。