Synofzik M
Institut für Ethik und Geschichte in der Medizin, Universität Tübingen, Schleichstrasse 8, 72074 Tübingen.
Nervenarzt. 2007 Apr;78(4):418-28. doi: 10.1007/s00115-006-2245-1.
Lacking clear empirical evidence and ethical obligations, decision-making about tube-feeding in patients with advanced dementia often presents as a difficult problem in clinical routine. Based on the principles of beneficence, non-maleficence and autonomy, an ethical analysis of the empirical evidence shows that tube-feeding should be avoided in many patients with advanced dementia: Recent studies demonstrate (1) that there is no proof of any benefit, (2) that tube-feeding often results in further harm to the dementia patient and (3) that the patient's will is not sufficiently taken into consideration. A practical model for interdisciplinary decision-making can account for these various difficulties and might improve the empirically and ethically highly complex process of decision-making about tube feeding in patients with advanced dementia.
由于缺乏明确的实证依据和道德义务,晚期痴呆患者的鼻饲决策在临床实践中常常是一个难题。基于行善、不伤害和自主原则,对实证依据进行的伦理分析表明,许多晚期痴呆患者应避免鼻饲:近期研究表明,(1)没有证据证明鼻饲有任何益处,(2)鼻饲常常会给痴呆患者带来更多伤害,(3)患者的意愿没有得到充分考虑。一个跨学科决策的实用模型可以解决这些各种难题,并可能改善晚期痴呆患者鼻饲决策这一在实证和伦理方面都高度复杂的过程。