Beelmann Andreas, Lösel Friedrich
Department of Psychoogy, University of Jena, Germany.
Psicothema. 2006 Aug;18(3):603-10.
Social skills training for children is becoming increasingly popular as a measure for developmental crime prevention. Although previous reviews of such programs have shown positive effects, they have also revealed problems of research design, outcome measures, and long-term follow up. Accordingly, this article reports on a recent meta-analysis of randomized evaluations of the effect of social skills training in preventing antisocial behavior and promoting social competence. Of 841 retrievable references, 84 research reports with a total of 136 treatment-control comparisons fulfilled the eligibility criteria. Results showed a small but significant overall positive effect of d = .39 at post-intervention and d = .28 at follow-up (3 months and later). Effect sizes were somewhat greater for outcome measures of social competence than for measures of antisocial behavior, particularly when delinquency was assessed. Cognitive-behavioral programs revealed the best results in terms of generalization over time and on outcome criteria. In addition, prevention measures indicated for children and adolescents who already manifested some behavioral problems had higher effect sizes than universal approaches. Because most studies dealt with small sample sizes, non-official outcome data, and measurements after less than one year, the results should be interpreted with caution. Further high-quality studies with long-term empirical outcome criteria are needed, particularly outside the United States.
作为一种预防犯罪的发展性措施,针对儿童的社交技能训练越来越受欢迎。尽管此前对这类项目的综述显示出了积极效果,但也揭示了研究设计、结果测量以及长期随访方面的问题。因此,本文报告了一项近期的荟萃分析,该分析针对社交技能训练在预防反社会行为和促进社会能力方面效果的随机评估。在841篇可检索参考文献中,84篇研究报告共包含136组治疗组与对照组的比较,符合纳入标准。结果显示,干预后总体有较小但显著的积极效果,效应量d = 0.39,随访时(3个月及以后)效应量d = 0.28。社会能力结果测量指标的效应量略大于反社会行为测量指标,尤其是在评估青少年犯罪时。就随时间推移的普遍性和结果标准而言,认知行为项目显示出最佳结果。此外,针对已经表现出一些行为问题的儿童和青少年的预防措施,其效应量高于普遍适用的方法。由于大多数研究样本量较小、采用非官方结果数据且测量时间不足一年,因此对结果的解释应谨慎。需要开展更多具有长期实证结果标准的高质量研究,尤其是在美国以外地区。