Santos Gilda, Santos Margarida, Farrington David P, da Agra Cândido, Castro Josefina, Cardoso Carla S
University of Porto, Portugal.
University Lusíada, Porto, Portugal.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2025 Mar;69(4):388-416. doi: 10.1177/0306624X231172645. Epub 2023 May 13.
Using an experimental design and a multi-measure and multi-informant approach, the current study sought to evaluate the impact of the early developmental prevention program "ZARPAR"-an intervention designed as a social and cognitive skills training program, that seeks to promote children's behavioral adjustment. A sample of elementary school children (experimental group = 37; control group = 66), attending Portuguese schools, was assessed before and 6 months after the intervention on the program's key-dimensions: behavioral problems, social skills, and executive functioning. Based on parent and teacher reports, the results largely suggested that the intervention had no effect or, for some dimensions, even the existence of negative outcomes. Possible reasons for these results are discussed. The current study highlights that, despite the overwhelmingly positive message about developmental prevention programs, not all interventions work, thus reinforcing the need for rigorous evaluations, in order to enhance the success of future interventions.
本研究采用实验设计以及多测量和多信息源方法,旨在评估早期发展预防项目“ZARPAR”的影响。该项目是一项旨在促进儿童行为调整的社会和认知技能培训干预项目。以葡萄牙学校的小学生为样本(实验组=37名;对照组=66名),在干预前和干预6个月后对该项目的关键维度进行评估:行为问题、社交技能和执行功能。基于家长和教师的报告,结果大体表明该干预没有效果,或者在某些维度上甚至存在负面结果。本文讨论了这些结果的可能原因。当前研究强调,尽管关于发展预防项目的信息大多是积极的,但并非所有干预都有效,因此加强严格评估很有必要,以便提高未来干预的成功率。