Kleinveld Johanna H, Timmermans Daniëlle R M, van den Berg Matthijs, van Eijk Jacques Th M, Ten Kate Leo P
EMGO-Institute, VU University Medical Center, Netherlands.
Prenat Diagn. 2007 Aug;27(8):757-64. doi: 10.1002/pd.1775.
The question addressed was: Does offering prenatal screening and receiving a negative screening outcome influence women's attachment to their unborn child?
Women were offered a nuchal translucency measurement, maternal serum screening, or no screening at all in a randomized controlled trial. Attachment was measured by a self-developed questionnaire at four points in time: before screening was offered, after the offer, after receiving the negative screening result (or at comparable points in time) and in the last trimester of pregnancy. In the last trimester, the Prenatal Attachment Inventory was also filled in.
Women who had been offered screening (n = 1031) showed more attachment (F(1,1415) = 19.42, p < .001) compared to women who had not been offered screening (n = 387). This difference disappeared later in pregnancy. At all points in time, negatively screened women (n = 466) had equal levels of attachment compared to screening decliners (n = 565). No difference was observed between women who received a negative result of the ultrasound screening (n = 285) as compared to the blood screening (n = 162).
Offering prenatal screening seems to temporarily increase attachment. However, this difference is very small. Attachment is not influenced by whether a blood screening or an ultrasound screening is performed.
所探讨的问题是:提供产前筛查并获得阴性筛查结果是否会影响女性与未出生胎儿的情感联结?
在一项随机对照试验中,为女性提供颈部透明带测量、母血清筛查,或根本不进行筛查。情感联结通过一份自行编制的问卷在四个时间点进行测量:在提供筛查之前、提供之后、收到阴性筛查结果之后(或在相应时间点)以及在妊娠晚期。在妊娠晚期,还填写了产前情感联结量表。
与未接受筛查的女性(n = 387)相比,接受筛查的女性(n = 1031)表现出更强的情感联结(F(1,1415) = 19.42,p <.001)。这种差异在妊娠后期消失。在所有时间点,接受阴性筛查的女性(n = 466)与拒绝筛查的女性(n = 565)的情感联结水平相当。接受超声筛查阴性结果的女性(n = 285)与接受血液筛查阴性结果的女性(n = 162)之间未观察到差异。
提供产前筛查似乎会暂时增强情感联结。然而,这种差异非常小。情感联结不受进行血液筛查还是超声筛查的影响。