Archer John, Ireland Jane L, Power Christina L
Department of Psychology, University of Central Lancashire, Preston PR1 2HE, Lancashire, UK.
Br J Soc Psychol. 2007 Jun;46(Pt 2):299-322. doi: 10.1348/014466606X114083.
This study assessed how behaviour indicative of bullying in prison settings is related to a variety of measures associated with aggression. Adult offenders (728 men and 525 women) from 11 prisons in the UK completed a 99-item checklist measuring behaviour indicative of 'bullying others' and of 'being bullied', as well as a range of other behavioural measures. They also completed a 43-item Response to Victimization Scale (RVS), asking about their responses to a scenario involving bullying; and measures of impulsiveness, and attributions about their aggression. Those classed as bullies showed, in response to the scenario, higher scores than non-bullies on direct verbal and physical aggression, indirect aggression, verbal and physical displaced aggression, and revenge plans and fantasies; and lower values for fear/avoidance; they also showed higher impulsiveness and instrumental and expressive attributions. Those classed as victims showed higher scores than non-victims for fear/avoidance, displaced physical aggression and impulsiveness. These main effects of bullying or victimization, with no interactions, are discussed in relation to hypotheses based on a previous four-category classification of those involved in bullying. There were large sex differences in the male direction for direct physical aggression, and in the female direction for fear/avoidance. There were smaller differences in the male direction for revenge, indirect aggression and direct verbal aggression. These are discussed in relation to an evolutionary theory of sex differences in aggression.
本研究评估了监狱环境中表明欺凌行为的表现与一系列与攻击性相关的测量指标之间的关系。来自英国11所监狱的成年罪犯(728名男性和525名女性)完成了一份99项的清单,该清单测量了表明“欺凌他人”和“受欺凌”的行为,以及一系列其他行为测量指标。他们还完成了一份43项的受害反应量表(RVS),询问他们对一个涉及欺凌场景的反应;以及冲动性测量指标和对自身攻击性的归因。那些被归类为欺凌者的人,在面对该场景时,在直接言语和身体攻击、间接攻击、言语和身体替代性攻击以及报复计划和幻想方面的得分高于非欺凌者;在恐惧/回避方面得分较低;他们还表现出更高的冲动性以及工具性和表达性归因。那些被归类为受害者的人在恐惧/回避、替代性身体攻击和冲动性方面的得分高于非受害者。根据之前对参与欺凌者的四类分类所提出的假设,讨论了欺凌或受害的这些主要影响,且不存在交互作用。在直接身体攻击方面存在较大的性别差异,男性表现更明显;在恐惧/回避方面也存在较大性别差异,女性表现更明显。在报复、间接攻击和直接言语攻击方面,男性方向的差异较小。结合攻击性性别差异的进化理论对这些差异进行了讨论。