Tobin David L, Banker Judith D, Weisberg Laura, Bowers Wayne
Tufts University School of Medicine, Springfield, Massachusetts, USA.
Int J Eat Disord. 2007 Dec;40(8):754-7. doi: 10.1002/eat.20426.
Although several studies have shown that eating disorders clinicians do not generally use treatment manuals, findings regarding what they do use have typically been vague, or closely linked to a particular theoretical approach. Our goal was to identify what eating disorder clinicians do with their patients in a more theoretically neutral context. We also sought to describe an empirically defined approach to psychotherapeutic practice as defined by clinicians via factor analysis.
A survey developed for this study was administered to 265 clinicians recruited online and at regional and international meetings for eating disorders professionals.
Only 6% of respondents reported they adhered closely to treatment manuals and 98% of the respondents indicated they used both behavioral and dynamically informed interventions. Factor analysis of clinicians' use of 32 therapeutic strategies suggested seven dimensions: Psychodynamic Interventions, Coping Skills Training, Family History, CBT, Contracts, Therapist Disclosure, and Patient Feelings.
The findings of this study suggest that most clinicians use a wide array of eating disorder treatment interventions drawn from empirically supported treatments, such as CBT-BN, and from treatments that have no randomized controlled trial support. Factor analysis suggested theoretically linked dimensions of treatment, but also dimensions that are common across models.
尽管多项研究表明,饮食失调症临床医生通常不使用治疗手册,但关于他们实际使用的方法的研究结果通常很模糊,或者与特定的理论方法紧密相关。我们的目标是在一个理论上更中立的背景下,确定饮食失调症临床医生对其患者采取的措施。我们还试图描述一种由临床医生通过因素分析确定的、基于实证的心理治疗实践方法。
针对本研究开发的一项调查问卷,被发放给了265名临床医生,这些医生是通过网络以及在地区和国际饮食失调症专业人士会议上招募的。
只有6%的受访者表示他们严格遵循治疗手册,98%的受访者表示他们同时使用了行为导向和动态导向的干预措施。对临床医生使用的32种治疗策略进行因素分析,得出了七个维度:心理动力干预、应对技能训练、家族病史、认知行为疗法、契约、治疗师自我表露和患者感受。
本研究结果表明,大多数临床医生使用了一系列饮食失调症治疗干预措施,这些措施既来自有实证支持的治疗方法,如认知行为疗法-暴食症,也来自没有随机对照试验支持的治疗方法。因素分析表明了治疗方法在理论上相互关联的维度,但也有各模型共有的维度。