Rothstein William G, Hannum Susan
Department of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Maryland, Baltimore County, Baltimore, MD 21250, USA.
J Prof Nurs. 2007 Jul-Aug;23(4):235-40. doi: 10.1016/j.profnurs.2007.01.008.
Relationships between registered nurses and physicians have often been described in terms of two models: one based on interactions between two health professions and one based on the patriarchy of male physicians and the deference of female nurses. To evaluate nurses' perceptions of the two models, 125 advanced practice nurses at a statewide professional conference completed a closed-ended self-administered questionnaire that asked about their relations with male and female physicians. Nurses rated male and female physicians very similarly; both groups were rated most favorably on their confidence in the nurse's expertise and least favorably on their recognition of the nurse's responsibilities unrelated to the care of individual patients. Nurses rated female physicians under the age of 50 more favorably than older female physicians and rated male physicians of all ages similarly. These findings provide greater support for the professional than for the gender model of nurse-physician relations.
一种基于两个医疗专业之间的互动,另一种基于男医生的父权制以及女护士的顺从。为了评估护士对这两种模式的看法,在一次全州范围的专业会议上,125名高级执业护士完成了一份封闭式的自填问卷,该问卷询问了她们与男医生和女医生的关系。护士对男医生和女医生的评价非常相似;两组在对护士专业知识的信任方面得分最高,而在对护士与个体患者护理无关的责任的认可方面得分最低。护士对50岁以下的女医生评价比对年龄较大的女医生更积极,对所有年龄段的男医生评价相似。这些发现为护士与医生关系的专业模式而非性别模式提供了更多支持。