Howard Siobhán, Hughes Brian M
National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland.
Br J Health Psychol. 2008 Nov;13(Pt 4):603-17. doi: 10.1348/135910707X238734. Epub 2007 Sep 7.
In aromatherapy, lavender aroma is reputed to assist with relaxation. However, while there is much anecdotal evidence to that effect, the empirical literature is very inconsistent. Failure to employ adequate placebos, proper blinding, objective measures, or screening of prior beliefs about aromatherapy means that many previous findings could have been influenced by expectancy biases. The present study sought to establish whether lavender aroma and/or expectancies affect post-stress relaxation.
A double-blind, 3 (aroma) x 3 (instruction) x 10 (time in minutes) mixed-factorial placebo-controlled trial.
In a laboratory, 96 healthy undergraduate women were exposed to lavender, placebo, or no aroma during physiologically assessed relaxation after an arousing cognitive task. Where an aroma was presented, an instructional priming procedure was used to manipulate participants' expectancies about the aroma's likely impact on their ability to relax.
Results showed no effect of aroma on galvanic skin response during relaxation. However, the nature of instructional prime was associated with relaxation patterns: when expecting the aroma to inhibit them, participants relaxed more; when expecting facilitation, participants relaxed less. The effect was not seen with regard to self-reported relaxation (as represented by changes in state anxiety) and was independent of ratings of attitudes towards aromatherapy.
The findings imply that the previous associations of lavender aroma with assisted relaxation may have been influenced by expectancy biases, and that the relevant expectancies are easily manipulable.
在芳香疗法中,薰衣草香气被认为有助于放松。然而,尽管有很多传闻证据支持这一效果,但实证文献却非常不一致。由于未能采用适当的安慰剂、正确的盲法、客观的测量方法或对芳香疗法先前信念的筛选,这意味着许多先前的研究结果可能受到期望偏差的影响。本研究旨在确定薰衣草香气和/或期望是否会影响应激后的放松。
一项双盲、3(香气)×3(指导语)×10(分钟时间)混合因子安慰剂对照试验。
在实验室中,96名健康的本科女性在完成一项引起情绪波动认知任务后,于生理评估的放松过程中分别接触薰衣草香气、安慰剂或无香气。当呈现香气时,采用一种指导性启动程序来操纵参与者对香气可能对其放松能力产生影响的期望。
结果显示,在放松过程中,香气对皮肤电反应没有影响。然而,指导性启动的性质与放松模式有关:当期望香气抑制放松时,参与者放松得更多;当期望促进放松时,参与者放松得更少。在自我报告的放松方面(以状态焦虑的变化表示)未观察到这种效应,且该效应与对芳香疗法态度的评分无关。
研究结果表明,先前薰衣草香气与辅助放松之间的关联可能受到期望偏差的影响,并且相关期望很容易被操纵。