Kim Linda S, McAnany J Jason, Alexander Kenneth R, Fishman Gerald A
Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60612-7234, USA.
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2007 Oct;48(10):4720-4. doi: 10.1167/iovs.07-0690.
To determine the relationship between intersession test repeatability in static perimetry and the degree of local sensitivity reduction in patients with retinitis pigmentosa (RP).
Visual field data were obtained from 27 patients with RP using FASTPAC 30-2 of the Humphrey Field Analyzer and stimulus sizes III and V. Each test was repeated at two subsequent visits after an initial practice session. An intersession sensitivity difference was defined for each patient at each measured point in the visual field by subtracting the sensitivity value obtained during session 2 from the value obtained during session 3 at the corresponding test location. In addition, the mean sensitivity value for sessions 2 and 3 was determined at each location for each patient.
Bland-Altman plots of intersession sensitivity differences as a function of mean sensitivities showed that test-retest variability was greatest at test regions with sensitivities of approximately 10 dB, with lower variability at locations with higher or lower sensitivity. The pattern of findings was similar for sizes III and V stimuli. The mean intersession sensitivity difference was +0.26 dB for stimulus size III and +0.45 dB for stimulus size V, representing a small improvement in sensitivity from session 2 to session 3.
Intersession repeatability of visual field measurements in patients with RP is nonmonotonically related to the magnitude of the sensitivity loss. Therefore, apparent changes in visual field sensitivity as a result of time or treatment should be evaluated in light of the degree of the expected variability at particular sensitivity levels.
确定视网膜色素变性(RP)患者静态视野检查中不同检查间的可重复性与局部敏感度降低程度之间的关系。
使用Humphrey视野分析仪的FASTPAC 30 - 2程序以及III和V视标大小,从27例RP患者获取视野数据。在初始练习环节后,每次检查在随后的两次就诊时重复进行。通过用第3次检查时在相应测试位置获得的敏感度值减去第2次检查时获得的敏感度值,为视野中每个测量点的每位患者定义不同检查间的敏感度差异。此外,为每位患者的每个位置确定第2次和第3次检查的平均敏感度值。
不同检查间敏感度差异作为平均敏感度函数的Bland - Altman图显示,在敏感度约为10 dB的测试区域,重测变异性最大,在敏感度较高或较低的位置变异性较低。对于III和V视标大小,结果模式相似。视标大小III的不同检查间平均敏感度差异为 +0.26 dB,视标大小V为 +0.45 dB,表明从第2次检查到第3次检查敏感度有小幅改善。
RP患者视野测量的不同检查间可重复性与敏感度损失程度呈非单调相关。因此,由于时间或治疗导致的视野敏感度明显变化应根据特定敏感度水平下预期变异性的程度进行评估。