Harasym Troy O, Tardi Paul G, Harasym Natashia L, Harvie Pierrot, Johnstone Sharon A, Mayer Lawrence D
Celator Pharmaceuticals Corp., Vancouver BC, V6P 6P2 Canada.
Oncol Res. 2007;16(8):361-74. doi: 10.3727/000000006783980937.
Whether anticancer drug combinations act synergistically or antagonistically often depends on the ratio of the agents being combined. We show here that combinations of irinotecan and floxuridine exhibit drug ratio-dependent cytotoxicity in a broad panel of tumor cell lines in vitro where a 1:1 molar ratio consistently provided synergy and avoided antagonism. In vivo delivery of irinotecan and floxuridine coencapsulated inside liposomes at the synergistic 1:1 molar ratio (referred to as CPX-1) lead to greatly enhanced efficacy compared to the two drugs administered as a saline-based cocktail in a number of human xenograft and murine tumor models. When compared to liposomal irinotecan or liposomal floxuridine, the therapeutic activity of CPX-1 in vivo was not only superior to the individual liposomal agents, but the extent of tumor growth inhibition was greater than that predicted for combining the activities of the individual agents. In contrast, liposome delivery of irinotecan:floxuridine ratios shown to be antagonistic in vitro provided antitumor activity that was actually less than that achieved with liposomal irinotecan alone, indicative of in vivo antagonism. Synergistic antitumor activity observed for CPX-1 was associated with maintenance of the 1:1 irinotecan:floxuridine molar ratio in plasma and tumor tissue over 16-24 h. In contrast, injection of the drugs combined in saline resulted in irinotecan:floxuridine ratios that changed 10-fold within 1 h in plasma and sevenfold within 4 h in tumor tissue. These results indicate that substantial improvements in the efficacy of drug combinations may be achieved by maintaining in vitro-identified synergistic drug ratios after systemic administration using drug delivery vehicles.
抗癌药物组合是产生协同作用还是拮抗作用通常取决于所组合药物的比例。我们在此表明,伊立替康和氟尿苷的组合在一系列体外肿瘤细胞系中表现出药物比例依赖性细胞毒性,其中1:1摩尔比始终产生协同作用并避免拮抗作用。在体内,以协同的1:1摩尔比(称为CPX-1)将伊立替康和氟尿苷共包封在脂质体内,与在多种人异种移植和小鼠肿瘤模型中以盐溶液混合形式给药的两种药物相比,疗效大大增强。与脂质体伊立替康或脂质体氟尿苷相比,CPX-1在体内的治疗活性不仅优于单个脂质体药物,而且肿瘤生长抑制程度大于将单个药物活性相加所预测的程度。相反,脂质体递送的伊立替康与氟尿苷的比例在体外显示为拮抗作用,其提供的抗肿瘤活性实际上低于单独使用脂质体伊立替康所达到的活性,表明存在体内拮抗作用。观察到CPX-1具有协同抗肿瘤活性,这与血浆和肿瘤组织中1:1的伊立替康与氟尿苷摩尔比在16 - 24小时内保持稳定有关。相比之下,注射盐溶液中混合的药物导致血浆中伊立替康与氟尿苷的比例在1小时内变化10倍,肿瘤组织中在4小时内变化7倍。这些结果表明,通过使用药物递送载体在全身给药后维持体外确定的协同药物比例,可大幅提高药物组合的疗效。