Darby Michele
Gene W. Hirschfeld School of Dental Hygiene, Old Dominion University, Norfolk, Va., USA.
J Dent Hyg. 2007 Fall;81(4):78. Epub 2007 Oct 1.
The literature highlights key benefits from debate as a teaching-learning strategy for developing critical thinking and analytical skills while fostering teamwork and communication. Authors report that this method of teaching-learning has been implemented successfully in nursing and occupational therapy programs and would benefit other academic programs in the health sciences, particularly in courses that cover controversial issues. Although there are disadvantages to using the debate as a teaching-learning strategy, the benefits far outweigh the disadvantages. In conclusion, debating is an effective pedagogical strategy because of the level of responsibility for learning and active involvement required by all student debaters. Moreover, it provides an experience by which students can develop competencies in researching current issues, preparing logical arguments, actively listening to various perspectives, differentiating between subjective and evidence-based information, asking cogent questions, integrating relevant information, and formulating their own opinions based on evidence. After the debate is over, students also report that the experience is FUN!
文献强调了辩论作为一种教学策略的关键益处,它有助于培养批判性思维和分析能力,同时促进团队合作与沟通。作者报告称,这种教学方法已在护理和职业治疗项目中成功实施,对健康科学领域的其他学术项目也有益处,尤其是在涉及有争议问题的课程中。尽管将辩论用作教学策略存在一些缺点,但益处远大于缺点。总之,辩论是一种有效的教学策略,因为它要求所有参与辩论的学生都承担学习责任并积极参与。此外,它为学生提供了一种体验,使他们能够在研究当前问题、准备逻辑论证、积极倾听各种观点、区分主观信息和基于证据的信息、提出有说服力的问题、整合相关信息以及基于证据形成自己的观点等方面培养能力。辩论结束后,学生们也表示这种体验很有趣!