Chan Engle Angela, Chung Joanne W Y, Wong Thomas K S
School of Nursing, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong SAR, China.
J Clin Nurs. 2008 Apr;17(8):1023-34. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2007.01997.x. Epub 2007 Dec 20.
This study uses two models of nursing practice, conventional and modular design, to compare nursing activities, hand hygiene, time efficiency and nurse-patient satisfaction in medical and surgical wards. Background. Learning from the SARS epidemic pointed to the importance of quality nursing practice considerations that minimize cross-transmission of infection while maximizing patient-focused care. Hence, a modular nursing model was adopted.
This study comprised pre- and postintervention phases. Data collection tools to evaluate modular nursing practice included a work sampling observation checklist, focused group interviews with nurses, questionnaires addressing nurses' perceived competence and caring attributes, a patient satisfaction questionnaire, and a hand hygiene audit. A series of education sessions were conducted between the two phases. Quantitative and qualitative analyses were used for data triangulation.
Modular nursing practice, focusing on continuity of care, led to changes in the nature of direct care activities and improvement in patient/family education frequency. Also, a general increase in nurses' hand washing frequency was noted. However, when nurses perceived time pressure, a lapse in hand hygiene compliance was found. Because of human resource and inefficiency issues, some nurses in the studied wards did not embrace geographical separation for infection control. Positive correlations were found for nurses' perceived infection control practice competence and their perceived caring attributes.
In examining nursing practice models within complex clinical situations, the significance lies not only in the model's effects but also in other operational outcomes.
本研究采用两种护理实践模式,即传统模式和模块化设计模式,对内科和外科病房的护理活动、手卫生、时间效率以及护士 - 患者满意度进行比较。背景。从非典疫情中吸取的教训表明,高质量护理实践考量的重要性在于在最大限度减少感染交叉传播的同时,最大化以患者为中心的护理。因此,采用了模块化护理模式。
本研究包括干预前和干预后阶段。用于评估模块化护理实践的数据收集工具包括工作抽样观察清单、对护士的焦点小组访谈、针对护士感知能力和关怀属性的问卷、患者满意度问卷以及手卫生审核。在两个阶段之间开展了一系列教育课程。采用定量和定性分析进行数据三角验证。
注重护理连续性的模块化护理实践导致直接护理活动的性质发生变化,患者/家属教育频率提高。此外,还注意到护士洗手频率普遍增加。然而,当护士感到时间压力时,发现手卫生依从性出现下降。由于人力资源和效率问题,研究病房中的一些护士并未接受为控制感染而进行的区域分隔。护士感知到的感染控制实践能力与其感知到的关怀属性之间存在正相关。
在复杂临床情境中审视护理实践模式时,其意义不仅在于该模式的效果,还在于其他操作结果。