Orton Matthew R, d'Arcy James A, Walker-Samuel Simon, Hawkes David J, Atkinson David, Collins David J, Leach Martin O
Cancer Research UK Clinical MR Research Group, Institute of Cancer Research and Royal Marsden NHS Foundation Trust, Sutton, Surrey SM2 5PT, UK.
Phys Med Biol. 2008 Mar 7;53(5):1225-39. doi: 10.1088/0031-9155/53/5/005. Epub 2008 Feb 11.
A description of the vascular input function is needed to obtain tissue kinetic parameter estimates from dynamic contrast enhanced MRI (DCE-MRI) data. This paper describes a general modelling framework for defining compact functional forms to describe vascular input functions. By appropriately specifying the components of this model it is possible to generate models that are realistic, and that ensure that the tissue concentration curves can be analytically calculated. This means that the computations necessary to estimate parameters from measured data are relatively efficient, which is important if such methods are to become of use in clinical practice. Three models defined by four parameters, using exponential, gamma-variate and cosine descriptions of the bolus, are described and their properties investigated using simulations. The results indicate that if there is no plasma fraction, then the proposed models are indistinguishable. When a small plasma fraction is present the exponential model gives parameter estimates that are biassed by up to 50%, while the other two models give very little bias; up to 10% but less than 5% in most cases. With a larger plasma fraction the exponential model is again biassed, the gamma-variate model has a small bias, but the cosine model has a very little bias and is indistinguishable from the model used to generate the data. The computational speed of the analytic approaches is compared with a fast-Fourier-transform-based numerical convolution approach. The analytic methods are nearly 10 times faster than the numerical methods for the isolated computation of the convolution, and around 4-5 times faster when used in an optimization routine to obtain parameter estimates. These results were obtained from five example data sets, one of which was examined in more detail to compare the estimates obtained using the different models, and with literature values.
要从动态对比增强磁共振成像(DCE-MRI)数据中获得组织动力学参数估计值,需要对血管输入函数进行描述。本文描述了一个通用的建模框架,用于定义紧凑的函数形式来描述血管输入函数。通过适当地指定该模型的组成部分,可以生成逼真的模型,并确保可以解析计算组织浓度曲线。这意味着从测量数据估计参数所需的计算相对高效,如果此类方法要在临床实践中得到应用,这一点很重要。描述了由四个参数定义的三种模型,使用团注的指数、伽马变量和余弦描述,并通过模拟研究了它们的特性。结果表明,如果没有血浆分数,那么所提出的模型是无法区分的。当存在少量血浆分数时,指数模型给出的参数估计偏差高达50%,而其他两种模型的偏差非常小;高达10%,但在大多数情况下小于5%。当血浆分数较大时,指数模型再次出现偏差,伽马变量模型有小偏差,但余弦模型偏差非常小,与用于生成数据的模型无法区分。将解析方法的计算速度与基于快速傅里叶变换的数值卷积方法进行了比较。对于卷积的单独计算,解析方法比数值方法快近10倍,在用于优化程序以获得参数估计时,速度快约4-5倍。这些结果来自五个示例数据集,其中一个进行了更详细的检查,以比较使用不同模型获得的估计值与文献值。