Yazici Yusuf, Bergman Martin, Pincus Theodore
New York University Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York, New York 10003, USA.
J Rheumatol. 2008 Apr;35(4):603-9. Epub 2008 Mar 1.
To analyze the time required to score different measures used to assess patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), as a guide to feasibility in standard care. The measures studied were a 28-Joint Count, Disease Activity Score (DAS), Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ), Multidimensional HAQ (MDHAQ), and various Routine Assessment of Patient Index Data (RAPID) scores derived from the MDHAQ.
Three rheumatologists at 3 sites performed and timed 28-joint counts in 20 different patients at each site. Each rheumatologist scored and timed identical data in 5 groups of 10 from the same 50 patients seen in standard clinical care, including 50 DAS28 indices using the DAS Website, 50 identical HAQ, and 50 identical MDHAQ from the same patients. The MDHAQ includes 10 activities self-assessed for physical function, 21 circle visual analog scales (VAS) (rather than 10 cm lines), and scoring templates on the questionnaire for physical function, patient self-report joint count and RAPID composite scores. RAPID3 includes the 3 Core Data Set measures, RAPID4 adds the self-report joint count to RAPID3, and RAPID5 adds a physician global estimate to RAPID4.
The median number of seconds to complete a 28-joint count was 90, compared to 41.9 s for a HAQ, 9.6 s for an MDHAQ RAPID3, and 19.4 s for RAPID5.
MDHAQ RAPID3 scores can be calculated in considerably less time than other RA measures, using scoring templates on the MDHAQ, to provide informative, feasible, quantitative measures for standard rheumatology clinical care.
分析对类风湿关节炎(RA)患者进行不同评估指标评分所需的时间,以此作为标准护理可行性的参考。所研究的指标包括28关节计数、疾病活动评分(DAS)、健康评估问卷(HAQ)、多维健康评估问卷(MDHAQ)以及从MDHAQ得出的各种患者指数数据常规评估(RAPID)评分。
三个地点的三位风湿病学家对每个地点的20名不同患者进行28关节计数并计时。每位风湿病学家对来自标准临床护理中相同50名患者的5组每组10名患者的数据进行评分并计时,包括使用DAS网站计算50个DAS28指数、50份相同的HAQ以及50份相同的MDHAQ。MDHAQ包括10项自我评估身体功能的活动、21个圆形视觉模拟量表(VAS)(而非10厘米长的线条)以及问卷上用于身体功能、患者自我报告关节计数和RAPID综合评分的评分模板。RAPID3包括3项核心数据集指标,RAPID4在RAPID3的基础上增加了自我报告关节计数,RAPID5在RAPID4的基础上增加了医生整体评估。
完成28关节计数的中位时间为90秒,相比之下,HAQ为41.9秒,MDHAQ RAPID3为9.6秒,RAPID5为19.4秒。
使用MDHAQ上的评分模板,计算MDHAQ RAPID3评分所需的时间比其他RA评估指标少得多,可为标准风湿病临床护理提供信息丰富、可行的定量指标。