Livingston Michael
AER Centre for Alcohol Policy Research, Turning Point Alcohol and Drug Centre, Fitzroy, Australia.
Addiction. 2008 Apr;103(4):619-28. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2008.02136.x.
A large number of studies have found links between alcohol outlet densities and assault rates in local areas. This study tests a variety of specifications of this link, focusing in particular on the possibility of a non-linear relationship.
Cross-sectional data on police-recorded assaults during high alcohol hours, liquor outlets and socio-demographic characteristics were obtained for 223 postcodes in Melbourne, Australia. These data were used to construct a series of models testing the nature of the relationship between alcohol outlet density and assault, while controlling for socio-demographic factors and spatial auto-correlation. Four types of relationship were examined: a normal linear relationship between outlet density and assault, a non-linear relationship with potential threshold or saturation densities, a relationship mediated by the socio-economic status of the neighbourhood and a relationship which takes into account the effect of outlets in surrounding neighbourhoods.
The model positing non-linear relationships between outlet density and assaults was found to fit the data most effectively. An increasing accelerating effect for the density of hotel (pub) licences was found, suggesting a plausible upper limit for these licences in Melbourne postcodes.
The study finds positive relationships between outlet density and assault rates and provides evidence that this relationship is non-linear and thus has critical values at which licensing policy-makers can impose density limits.
大量研究发现了当地酒精销售点密度与攻击率之间的联系。本研究对这种联系的各种规格进行了测试,尤其关注非线性关系的可能性。
获取了澳大利亚墨尔本223个邮政编码地区警方记录的高酒精消费时段攻击事件、酒类销售点以及社会人口特征的横断面数据。这些数据被用于构建一系列模型,以测试酒精销售点密度与攻击事件之间关系的性质,同时控制社会人口因素和空间自相关性。研究考察了四种类型的关系:销售点密度与攻击事件之间的正常线性关系、具有潜在阈值或饱和密度的非线性关系、由邻里社会经济地位介导的关系以及考虑周边邻里销售点影响的关系。
发现假定销售点密度与攻击事件之间存在非线性关系的模型最能拟合数据。研究发现酒店(酒吧)执照密度具有递增加速效应,这表明墨尔本邮政编码地区这些执照存在一个合理的上限。
该研究发现销售点密度与攻击率之间存在正相关关系,并提供证据表明这种关系是非线性的,因此存在关键值,许可政策制定者可据此设定密度限制。