Barker Judith C, Horton Sarah B
Department of Anthropology, History & Social Medicine and Center to Address Disparities in Children's Oral Health, University of California San Francisco, 3333 California Street, Suite 485, San Francisco, CA 94143-0850, USA.
BMC Oral Health. 2008 Mar 31;8:8. doi: 10.1186/1472-6831-8-8.
Latino children experience a higher prevalence of caries than do children in any other racial/ethnic group in the US. This paper examines the intersections among four societal sectors or contexts of care which contribute to oral health disparities for low-income, preschool Latino1 children in rural California.
Findings are reported from an ethnographic investigation, conducted in 2005-2006, of family, community, professional/dental and policy/regulatory sectors or contexts of care that play central roles in creating or sustaining low income, rural children's poor oral health status. The study community of around 9,000 people, predominantly of Mexican-American origin, was located in California's agricultural Central Valley. Observations in homes, community facilities, and dental offices within the region were supplemented by in-depth interviews with 30 key informants (such as dental professionals, health educators, child welfare agents, clinic administrators and regulatory agents) and 47 primary caregivers (mothers) of children at least one of whom was under 6 years of age.
Caregivers did not always recognize visible signs of caries among their children, nor respond quickly unless children also complained of pain. Fluctuating seasonal eligibility for public health insurance intersected with limited community infrastructure and civic amenities, including lack of public transportation, to create difficulties in access to care. The non-fluoridated municipal water supply is not widely consumed because of fears about pesticide pollution. If the dentist brought children into the clinic for multiple visits, this caused the accompanying parent hardship and occasionally resulted in the loss of his or her job. Few general dentists had received specific training in how to handle young patients. Children's dental fear and poor provider-parent communication were exacerbated by a scarcity of dentists willing to serve rural low-income populations. Stringent state fiscal reimbursement policies further complicated the situation.
Several societal sectors or contexts of care significantly intersected to produce or sustain poor oral health care for children. Parental beliefs and practices, leading for example to delay in seeking care, were compounded by lack of key community or economic resources, and the organization and delivery of professional dental services. In the context of state-mandated policies and procedures, these all worked to militate against children receiving timely care that would considerably reduce oral health disparities among this highly disadvantaged population.
在美国,拉丁裔儿童的龋齿患病率高于其他任何种族/族裔群体的儿童。本文探讨了四个社会部门或照护环境之间的相互关系,这些因素导致了加利福尼亚州农村地区低收入学龄前拉丁裔儿童的口腔健康差异。
报告的结果来自2005年至2006年进行的一项人种学调查,该调查涉及家庭、社区、专业/牙科以及政策/监管部门或照护环境,这些部门或环境在造成或维持低收入农村儿童不良口腔健康状况方面发挥着核心作用。研究社区约有9000人,主要是墨西哥裔美国人,位于加利福尼亚州的农业中央谷地。通过对30名关键信息提供者(如牙科专业人员、健康教育工作者、儿童福利机构工作人员、诊所管理人员和监管机构工作人员)以及47名儿童的主要照料者(母亲)进行深入访谈,对该地区家庭、社区设施和牙科诊所的观察进行了补充,这些儿童中至少有一名年龄在6岁以下。
照料者并不总是能识别出孩子龋齿的明显迹象,除非孩子也抱怨疼痛,否则他们不会迅速做出反应。公共医疗保险的季节性资格波动,加上社区基础设施和城市便利设施有限,包括缺乏公共交通,导致就医困难。由于担心农药污染,未加氟的市政供水未被广泛饮用。如果牙医让孩子多次到诊所就诊,这会给陪同的家长带来困难,有时还会导致其失业。很少有普通牙医接受过如何治疗年轻患者的专门培训。愿意为农村低收入人群服务的牙医短缺,加剧了儿童对牙科治疗和医患沟通不良的恐惧。严格的州财政报销政策使情况更加复杂。
几个社会部门或照护环境显著相互作用,导致或维持了儿童不良的口腔医疗保健状况。父母的观念和行为,例如导致就医延迟,因缺乏关键的社区或经济资源以及专业牙科服务的组织和提供而更加严重。在国家规定的政策和程序背景下,这些因素都不利于儿童获得及时的治疗,而及时治疗可以大大减少这一高度弱势群体之间的口腔健康差异。