Suppr超能文献

[连续性——调整——自主性——医生——患者——前东德医学文化哲学概述]

[Continuity--adjustment--autonomy--physician--patient--an overview of medical cultural philosophy in former East Germany].

作者信息

Belau D

出版信息

Offentl Gesundheitswes. 1991 Dec;53 Suppl 3:203-15.

PMID:1840216
Abstract

The author probes into the "culture" of medical thinking in the former GDR in respect of the interlinking of socialisation of the doctor, within the framework of socialism, with the fate of the patient; the fundamentals of the development of science and of the pattern of cultural life; and the development of moral consciousness and health policy under the influence of Marxist-Leninist teachings. (One should not neglect the difference made by the author between "official Marxism-Leninism as decreed by the state" and "Marxist theory" as well as "public level of consciousness".) Errors of judgment, illusions, so-called "noble" ideals of the medical profession such as ambitiousness, engagedness, and readiness to shoulder responsibilities, were interwoven with the trend to functionalism, to keep the party bureaucracy of the SED in power. One of the thematic points of emphasis was the "changing of paradigms in medicine", such as the hostility to psychology as a feature of GDR socialism, or the sociopolitically dictated condemnation of non-institutional or "alternative" medicine. The author sees a basic trend to technocracy in GDR medicine. He shows up trends to "moral remote control" of the doctor, to a deliberately practised illusionment, a systematically engineered demounting of decisions based on moral constraints--such demounting being promoted both in the doctor's mind and in actual practice--and to eliminating emotional obstacles officially construed as "interfering" with a strictly objectified doctor-patient relationship. Nothing in this context can be soft-pedalled and excused. The author points specifically to the officially promoted vision of a "successful repair and construction of a New Man". Within the context of socialist ideal views and actual socialisation of the doctor there are similarities between the balance-sheets of 1945 and 1989 in Germany without attempting to suggest that this amounts to a comparison on the same level with the genocide and war guilt of the National Socialist era. Guilt is a burden on the mind, but non-assessed guilt and lack of a possibility of redemption destroys humans. The article is a plea against an increasing tendency to criminalize the former GDR citizen and the doctors. "It will be necessary to honestly review the past history embodying my own errors, mistaken concepts and illusions." All this is only a first approximation to an important and complex subject. It is the author's aim to promote a better understanding between the former GDR citizens and those of West Germany.

摘要

作者从社会主义框架下医生社会化与患者命运的关联、科学发展的基础与文化生活模式以及在马克思列宁主义教义影响下道德意识和卫生政策的发展等方面,探究了前东德医学思维的“文化”。(不应忽视作者所指出的“国家规定的官方马克思列宁主义”与“马克思主义理论”以及“公众意识水平”之间的差异。)判断失误、幻想,以及医学职业中所谓的“高尚”理想,如雄心壮志、敬业精神和愿意承担责任等,都与功能主义倾向交织在一起,以使德国统一社会党的党的官僚机构掌权。其中一个重点主题是“医学范式的转变”,比如以东德社会主义的一个特征表现出的对心理学的敌意,或者社会政治层面上对非机构性或“替代”医学的谴责。作者认为东德医学存在技术统治论的基本趋势。他揭示了对医生的“道德遥控”趋势、蓄意制造的幻想、基于道德约束的决策的系统性瓦解——这种瓦解在医生的思维和实际操作中都得到了推动——以及消除被官方认定为“干扰”严格客观化医患关系的情感障碍。在这种背景下,没有任何事情可以轻描淡写或开脱。作者特别指出了官方所宣扬的“成功修复和塑造新人”的愿景。在社会主义理想观念和医生实际社会化的背景下,1945年和1989年德国的情况存在相似之处,但无意暗示这等同于与纳粹时代的种族灭绝和战争罪责处于同一层面的比较。罪责是心灵的负担,但未经评估的罪责和无法救赎的可能性会毁灭人类。这篇文章呼吁反对日益增长的将前东德公民和医生定罪的趋势。“有必要诚实地审视包含我自己的错误、错误观念和幻想的过去历史。”所有这些只是对一个重要而复杂主题的初步探讨。作者的目的是促进前东德公民和西德公民之间更好的理解。

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验