Nanthakumar Kumaraswamy, Massé Stephane, Umapathy Karthikeyan, Dorian Paul, Sevaptsidis Elias, Waxman Menashe
University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.
CMAJ. 2008 May 20;178(11):1451-7. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.071867. Epub 2008 May 1.
The ability of an electrical discharge to stimulate the heart depends on the duration of the pulse, the voltage and the current density that reaches the heart. Stun guns deliver very short electrical pulses with minimal amount of current at high voltages. We discuss external stimulation of the heart by high voltage discharges and review studies that have evaluated the potential of stun guns to stimulate cardiac muscle. Despite theoretical analyses and animal studies which suggest that stun guns cannot and do not affect the heart, 3 independent investigators have shown cardiac stimulation by stun guns. Additional research studies involving people are needed to resolve the conflicting theoretical and experimental findings and to aid in the design of stun guns that are unable to stimulate the heart.
放电刺激心脏的能力取决于脉冲持续时间、电压以及到达心脏的电流密度。电击枪会在高电压下发出极短的电脉冲,且电流极小。我们讨论了高压放电对心脏的外部刺激,并回顾了评估电击枪刺激心肌潜力的研究。尽管理论分析和动物研究表明电击枪不会也无法影响心脏,但有3位独立研究者已证明电击枪能刺激心脏。需要开展更多涉及人体的研究,以解决相互矛盾的理论和实验结果,并协助设计无法刺激心脏的电击枪。