Harris F M, Kendall M, Bentley A, Maguire R, Worth A, Murray S, Boyd K, Brown D, Kearney N, Sheikh A
Division of Community Health Sciences: General Practice Section, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK.
Eur J Cancer Care (Engl). 2008 Jul;17(4):377-86. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2354.2007.00880.x.
The objectives of this review were to assess the methods and approaches applied to end-of-life cancer research based on papers focusing on approaches or methodological issues related to seeking the views of people affected by terminal cancer. A comprehensive search of 10 databases (January 1980-February 2004) was undertaken. References were screened, quality assessed and data extracted by two reviewers. Analysis followed a meta-narrative approach. Fifteen papers were included. They discussed 'traditional' approaches, such as focus groups, interviews, surveys, as well as innovative approaches allied to the arts. They reveal that mixed methods are gaining popularity. The emotional demands placed on researchers and the ethical issues involved in this research area were also discussed. We concluded that researchers should embrace innovative approaches from other areas of social science, such as the use of arts-based techniques. This may facilitate recruitment of the hard-to-reach groups and engage with experiences that may be otherwise difficult to verbalize. Although researching the needs of the dying carries challenges, these are not the exclusive domain of the cancer field. This study reveals that diverse methods, from research-based drama to postal questionnaires, can enhance end-of-life research. However, this review reveals the need for more methodological work to be undertaken and disseminated.
本综述的目的是,基于聚焦于与寻求晚期癌症患者观点相关的方法或方法学问题的论文,评估应用于临终癌症研究的方法和途径。对10个数据库进行了全面检索(1980年1月至2004年2月)。两名评审人员对参考文献进行筛选、质量评估并提取数据。分析采用元叙事方法。纳入了15篇论文。它们讨论了“传统”方法,如焦点小组、访谈、调查,以及与艺术相关的创新方法。它们表明混合方法越来越受欢迎。还讨论了对研究人员的情感要求以及该研究领域涉及的伦理问题。我们得出结论,研究人员应采用社会科学其他领域的创新方法,如使用基于艺术的技术。这可能有助于招募难以接触到的群体,并接触到那些可能难以用言语表达的经历。尽管研究临终者的需求存在挑战,但这些并非癌症领域所独有。这项研究表明,从基于研究的戏剧到邮政问卷等多种方法,都可以加强临终研究。然而,本综述表明需要开展并传播更多的方法学研究工作。