Nicholls Michael E R, Loftus Andrea M, Gevers Wim
Department of Psychology, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria, Australia.
Psychon Bull Rev. 2008 Apr;15(2):413-8. doi: 10.3758/pbr.15.2.413.
The mental representation of numbers along a line oriented left to right affects spatial cognition, facilitating responses in the ipsilateral hemispace (the spatial-numerical association of response codes [SNARC] effect). We investigated whether the number/space association is the result of an attentional shift or response selection. Previous research has often introduced covert left/right response cues by presenting targets to the left or the right. The present study avoided left/right cues by requiring forced choice upper/lower luminance discriminations to two mirror-reversed luminance gradients (the grayscale task). The grayscale stimuli were overlaid with strings of (1) low numbers, (2) high numbers, and (3) nonnumerical characters. In Experiment 1, 20 dextrals judged the number's magnitude and then indicated whether the upper/lower grayscale was darker. Results showed leftward and rightward attentional biases for low and high numbers, respectively. Demands to process numbers along a left/right line were made less explicit in Experiment 2 (N = 18 dextrals), using (1) a parity judgment and (2) arbitrary linguistic labels for top/bottom. Once again, a spatial congruency effect was observed. Because the response (up/down) was orthogonal to the dimension of interest (left/right), the effect of number cannot be attributed to late-stage response congruencies. This study required unspeeded responses to stimuli presented in free vision, whereas other experiments have used speeded responses. Understanding the time course of number-space effects may, therefore, be important to the debate associated with response selection.
数字在从左到右排列的一条线上的心理表征会影响空间认知,促进同侧半空间中的反应(反应编码的空间-数字关联 [SNARC] 效应)。我们研究了数字/空间关联是注意力转移还是反应选择的结果。以往的研究常常通过将目标呈现给左侧或右侧来引入隐蔽的左/右反应线索。本研究通过要求对两个镜像反转的亮度梯度进行强制选择的上/下亮度辨别(灰度任务)来避免左/右线索。灰度刺激上叠加有(1) 小数字、(2) 大数字和(3) 非数字字符的字符串。在实验1中,20名右利手者判断数字的大小,然后指出上/下灰度是否更暗。结果分别显示了小数字和大数字的向左和向右注意力偏差。在实验2(N = 18名右利手者)中,使用(1) 奇偶判断和(2) 用于顶部/底部的任意语言标签,使沿左/右线处理数字的要求不那么明确。再次观察到空间一致性效应。由于反应(上/下)与感兴趣的维度(左/右)正交,数字的效应不能归因于后期的反应一致性。本研究要求对自由视觉中呈现的刺激进行非快速反应,而其他实验使用了快速反应。因此,了解数字-空间效应的时间进程可能对与反应选择相关的争论很重要。