Scott John G, Cohen Deborah, Dicicco-Bloom Barbara, Miller William L, Stange Kurt C, Crabtree Benjamin F
University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, Department of Family Medicine, Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, New Brunswick, New Jersey, USA.
Ann Fam Med. 2008 Jul-Aug;6(4):315-22. doi: 10.1370/afm.860.
Clinicians often have an intuitive understanding of how their relationships with patients foster healing. Yet we know little empirically about the experience of healing and how it occurs between clinicians and patients. Our purpose was to create a model that identifies how healing relationships are developed and maintained.
Primary care clinicians were purposefully selected as exemplar healers. Patients were selected by these clinicians as having experienced healing relationships. In-depth interviews, designed to elicit stories of healing relationships, were conducted with patients and clinicians separately. A multidisciplinary team analyzed the interviews using an iterative process, leading to the development of case studies for each clinician-patient dyad. A comparative analysis across dyads was conducted to identify common components of healing relationships
Three key processes emerged as fostering healing relationships: (1) valuing/creating a nonjudgmental emotional bond; (2) appreciating power/consciously managing clinician power in ways that would most benefit the patient; and (3) abiding/displaying a commitment to caring for patients over time. Three relational outcomes result from these processes: trust, hope, and a sense of being known. Clinician competencies that facilitate these processes are self-confidence, emotional self-management, mindfulness, and knowledge.
Healing relationships have an underlying structure and lead to important patient-centered outcomes. This conceptual model of clinician-patient healing relationships may be generalizable to other kinds of healing relationships.
临床医生常常直观地理解他们与患者的关系如何促进康复。然而,我们从实证角度对康复体验以及它在临床医生和患者之间如何发生了解甚少。我们的目的是创建一个模型,以确定康复关系是如何发展和维持的。
初级保健临床医生被特意选为典型的治疗者。这些临床医生挑选出经历过康复关系的患者。分别对患者和临床医生进行了深度访谈,旨在引出康复关系的故事。一个多学科团队采用迭代过程对访谈进行分析,从而为每对临床医生 - 患者二元组开发案例研究。对各二元组进行比较分析,以确定康复关系的共同组成部分。
出现了三个促进康复关系的关键过程:(1)重视/建立无评判的情感纽带;(2)认识权力/以最有利于患者的方式有意识地管理临床医生的权力;(3)坚持/展现长期关爱患者的承诺。这些过程产生了三种关系结果:信任、希望和被了解的感觉。促进这些过程的临床医生能力包括自信、情绪自我管理、正念和知识。
康复关系有其潜在结构,并导致以患者为中心的重要结果。这种临床医生 - 患者康复关系的概念模型可能适用于其他类型的康复关系。