Sievers Amy C, Lewey Jenifer, Musafiri Placide, Franke Molly F, Bucyibaruta Blaise J, Stulac Sara N, Rich Michael L, Karema Corine, Daily Johanna P
Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Malar J. 2008 Aug 27;7:167. doi: 10.1186/1475-2875-7-167.
Malaria control is currently receiving significant international commitment. As part of this commitment, Rwanda has undertaken a two-pronged approach to combating malaria via mass distribution of long-lasting insecticidal-treated nets and distribution of antimalarial medications by community health workers. This study attempted to measure the impact of these interventions on paediatric hospitalizations for malaria and on laboratory markers of disease severity.
A retrospective analysis of hospital records pre- and post-community-based malaria control interventions at a district hospital in rural Rwanda was performed. The interventions took place in August 2006 in the region served by the hospital and consisted of mass insecticide treated net distribution and community health workers antimalarial medication disbursement. The study periods consisted of the December-February high transmission seasons pre- and post-rollout. The record review examined a total of 551 paediatric admissions to identify 1) laboratory-confirmed malaria, defined by thick smear examination, 2) suspected malaria, defined as fever and symptoms consistent with malaria in the absence of an alternate cause, and 3) all-cause admissions. To define the impact of the intervention on clinical markers of malaria disease, trends in admission peripheral parasitaemia and haemoglobin were analyzed. To define accuracy of clinical diagnoses, trends in proportions of malaria admissions which were microscopy-confirmed before and after the intervention were examined. Finally, to assess overall management of febrile illnesses antibiotic use was described.
Of the 551 total admissions, 268 (48.6%) and 437 (79.3%) were attributable to laboratory-confirmed and suspected malaria, respectively. The absolute number of admissions due to suspected malaria was smaller during the post-intervention period (N = 150) relative to the pre-intervention period (N = 287), in spite of an increase in the absolute number of hospitalizations due to other causes during the post-intervention period. The percentage of suspected malaria admissions that were laboratory-confirmed was greater during the pre-intervention period (80.4%) relative to the post-intervention period (48.1%, prevalence ratio [PR]: 1.67; 95% CI: 1.39 - 2.02; chi-squared p-value < 0.0001). Among children admitted with laboratory-confirmed malaria, the risk of high parasitaemia was higher during the pre-intervention period relative to the post-intervention period (age-adjusted PR: 1.62; 95% CI: 1.11 - 2.38; chi-squared p-value = 0.004), and the risk of severe anaemia was more than twofold greater during the pre-intervention period (age-adjusted PR: 2.47; 95% CI: 0.84 - 7.24; chi-squared p-value = 0.08). Antibiotic use was common, with 70.7% of all children with clinical malaria and 86.4% of children with slide-negative malaria receiving antibacterial therapy.
This study suggests that both admissions for malaria and laboratory markers of clinical disease among children may be rapidly reduced following community-based malaria control efforts. Additionally, this study highlights the problem of over-diagnosis and over-treatment of malaria in malaria-endemic regions, especially as malaria prevalence falls. More accurate diagnosis and management of febrile illnesses is critically needed both now and as fever aetiologies change with further reductions in malaria.
疟疾防控目前得到了国际社会的重大支持。作为这一支持的一部分,卢旺达采取了双管齐下的方法来抗击疟疾,即大规模分发长效驱虫蚊帐,并由社区卫生工作者分发抗疟药物。本研究试图衡量这些干预措施对疟疾患儿住院率以及疾病严重程度实验室指标的影响。
对卢旺达农村一家地区医院在基于社区的疟疾防控干预措施实施前后的医院记录进行回顾性分析。干预措施于2006年8月在该医院服务的地区开展,包括大规模分发驱虫蚊帐和社区卫生工作者发放抗疟药物。研究时间段包括干预措施推出前后的12月至2月高传播季节。记录审查共检查了551例儿科住院病例,以确定:1)实验室确诊的疟疾,通过厚涂片检查定义;2)疑似疟疾,定义为发热且有与疟疾相符的症状但无其他病因;3)所有病因导致的住院病例。为确定干预措施对疟疾疾病临床指标的影响,分析了住院时外周血寄生虫血症和血红蛋白的变化趋势。为确定临床诊断的准确性,检查了干预前后显微镜确诊的疟疾住院病例比例的变化趋势。最后,为评估发热性疾病的总体管理情况,描述了抗生素的使用情况。
在551例住院病例中,分别有268例(48.6%)和437例(79.3%)归因于实验室确诊的疟疾和疑似疟疾。尽管干预后因其他原因导致的住院绝对数有所增加,但干预后因疑似疟疾导致的住院绝对数(N = 150)相对于干预前(N = 287)有所减少。干预前实验室确诊的疑似疟疾住院病例百分比(80.4%)高于干预后(48.1%),患病率比(PR):1.67;95%置信区间:1.39 - 2.02;卡方p值<0.0001。在实验室确诊为疟疾的住院儿童中,干预前高寄生虫血症的风险高于干预后(年龄调整PR:1.62;95%置信区间:1.11 - 2.38;卡方p值 = 0.004),干预前严重贫血的风险是干预后的两倍多(年龄调整PR:2.47;95%置信区间:0.84 - 7.24;卡方p值 = 0.08)。抗生素使用很普遍,所有临床诊断为疟疾的儿童中有70.7%以及镜检阴性疟疾患儿中有86.4%接受了抗菌治疗。
本研究表明,基于社区的疟疾防控措施实施后,儿童疟疾住院率和临床疾病的实验室指标可能会迅速降低。此外,本研究突出了疟疾流行地区疟疾过度诊断和过度治疗的问题,尤其是随着疟疾患病率下降。无论是现在还是随着疟疾进一步减少导致发热病因发生变化,都迫切需要更准确地诊断和管理发热性疾病。