Jandial Sharmila, Myers Andrea, Wise Elspeth, Foster Helen E
Musculoskeletal Research Group, Newcastle University, Newcastle Upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
J Pediatr. 2009 Feb;154(2):267-71. doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2008.08.013. Epub 2008 Sep 27.
To assess self-rated confidence in pediatric musculoskeletal (pMSK) clinical assessment in trainees and experienced doctors in primary care and selected secondary care specialties to whom children with MSK problems are likely to present.
Attendees at programmed postgraduate teaching sessions within a health care region of the United Kingdom completed an anonymous questionnaire to self-rate confidence in pMSK assessment compared with other bodily systems and describe exposure to MSK teaching.
Respondents (n = 346) were qualified from 23 different medical schools (United Kingdom and 9 non-United Kingdom) and included trainees in Primary Care (n = 75), Pediatrics (n = 39), Emergency (n = 39), Orthopedics (n = 40), and experienced doctors in Primary Care (n = 93), and Pediatrics (n = 60). Self-rated confidence in pMSK assessment was low; the majority had "no" or "some" confidence (21% and 53%, respectively). Conversely, most respondents were confident "in most aspects" or "very confident" for cardiovascular, respiratory, and abdominal systems. pMSK ranked lowest below all other systems. Most respondents (92%) recalled some teaching of adult MSK medicine, mostly at undergraduate level. Fewer (51%) recalled any teaching of pMSK medicine.
Self-rated confidence in pMSK assessment was lowest, compared with other bodily systems, within doctors to whom children with MSK problems are likely to present. Core clinical skills are learnt at undergraduate level, and this study reflects poor levels of pMSK training which needs to be addressed.
评估基层医疗及部分二级医疗专科领域的实习医生和经验丰富的医生对小儿肌肉骨骼(pMSK)临床评估的自评信心,这些专科是患有肌肉骨骼问题的儿童可能就诊的科室。
在英国一个医疗保健区域参加研究生课程教学的人员完成了一份匿名问卷,以自评与其他身体系统相比对pMSK评估的信心,并描述接受肌肉骨骼教学的情况。
受访者(n = 346)毕业于23所不同的医学院校(英国的和9所非英国的),包括基层医疗实习医生(n = 75)、儿科实习医生(n = 39)、急诊科实习医生(n = 39)、骨科实习医生(n = 40),以及基层医疗经验丰富的医生(n = 93)和儿科经验丰富的医生(n = 60)。对pMSK评估的自评信心较低;大多数人“没有”或“有一些”信心(分别为21%和53%)。相反,大多数受访者对心血管、呼吸和腹部系统“在大多数方面”有信心或“非常有信心”。pMSK在所有其他系统中排名最低。大多数受访者(92%)回忆起一些成人肌肉骨骼医学的教学内容,大多是在本科阶段。较少受访者(51%)回忆起任何小儿肌肉骨骼医学的教学内容。
与其他身体系统相比,在可能接待患有肌肉骨骼问题儿童的医生中,对pMSK评估的自评信心最低。核心临床技能是在本科阶段学习的,本研究反映出小儿肌肉骨骼培训水平较差,需要加以解决。