van Ijzendoorn Marinus H, Bard Kim A, Bakermans-Kranenburg Marian J, Ivan Krisztina
Centre for Child & Family Studies at Leiden University, P.O. Box 9555, 2300 RB Leiden, The Netherlands.
Dev Psychobiol. 2009 Mar;51(2):173-85. doi: 10.1002/dev.20356.
Forty-six nursery-reared chimpanzee infants (22 females and 24 males) receiving either standard care (n = 29) or responsive care (n = 17) at the Great Ape Nursery at Yerkes participated in this study. Standard care (ST) consisted primarily of peer-rearing, with humans providing essential health-related care. Responsive care (RC) consisted of an additional 4 hr of interaction 5 days a week with human caregivers who were specially trained to enhance species-typical chimpanzee socio-emotional and communicative development. At 9 months, ST and RC chimpanzees were examined with the Bayley Scales for Infant Development to assess their Mental Development Index (MDI). At 12 months, the chimpanzees were assessed with their human caregivers in the Ainsworth Strange Situation Procedure (SSP). In this first study to use the SSP in chimpanzees, nursery-reared chimpanzees exhibited the definite patterns of distress, proximity seeking, and exploration that underpin the SSP for human infants. In ST chimpanzees the attachment classification distribution was similar to that of human infants raised in Greek or Romanian orphanages. RC chimpanzees showed less disorganized attachment to their human caregivers, had a more advanced cognitive development, and displayed less object attachment compared to ST chimpanzees. Responsive care stimulates chimpanzees' cognitive and emotional development, and is an important factor in ameliorating some of the adverse effects of institutional care.
46只在耶基斯大猿保育所接受标准护理(n = 29)或响应式护理(n = 17)的人工饲养黑猩猩幼崽(22只雌性和24只雄性)参与了本研究。标准护理(ST)主要包括同伴饲养,人类提供基本的健康相关护理。响应式护理(RC)包括每周5天额外4小时与经过专门培训以促进黑猩猩典型社会情感和沟通发展的人类照顾者互动。9个月大时,对接受标准护理和响应式护理的黑猩猩进行贝利婴儿发展量表测试,以评估其心理发展指数(MDI)。12个月大时,在安斯沃思陌生情境程序(SSP)中与人类照顾者一起对黑猩猩进行评估。在这项首次在黑猩猩中使用SSP的研究中,人工饲养的黑猩猩表现出了构成人类婴儿SSP基础的明确的痛苦、寻求亲近和探索模式。接受标准护理的黑猩猩的依恋分类分布与在希腊或罗马尼亚孤儿院长大的人类婴儿相似。与接受标准护理的黑猩猩相比,接受响应式护理的黑猩猩对人类照顾者的混乱依恋较少,认知发展更先进,对物体的依恋也较少。响应式护理刺激黑猩猩的认知和情感发展,是减轻机构护理一些不利影响的重要因素。