Melin M, Bonnevier A, Cardell M, Hogan L, Herbst A
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Clinical Sciences, Lund University Hospital, Lund, Sweden.
BJOG. 2008 Dec;115(13):1669-75. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-0528.2008.01949.x.
To assess the occurrence of ST-interval segment changes of the fetal electrocardiogram (ECG) and cardiotocographic (CTG) abnormalities preceding acidaemia at birth.
Case-control study.
University hospital labour ward.
Newborns with severe cord artery metabolic acidaemia (pH < 7.00 and lactate > or = 10 mmol/l; n= 24), moderate metabolic acidaemia (pH 7.00-7.09 and lactate > or = 10; n= 48), acidaemia (pH 7.00-7.09; n= 52), pre-acidaemia (pH 7.10-7.19; n= 265), and controls (pH > or = 7.20; n= 117).
Monitoring traces were assessed blinded to outcome.
CTG and ST changes.
Any ST event occurred significantly more often among cases with severe (79%) and moderate (75%) metabolic acidaemia than among controls (50%). The difference was restricted to baseline T/QRS rises and to the second stage of labour, during which any event only occurred significantly more often among cases with severe metabolic acidaemia (62%) than among controls (38%). ST events coincided with abnormal CTG patterns in 67, 44, 40, and 28% of cases with severe and moderate metabolic acidaemia, acidaemia, and pre-acidaemia, respectively, and in 12% of controls. ST events with intermediary CTG were similarly frequent in the case groups (0-6%) as in the controls (4%). The ST guidelines stated intervention in 96, 62, 73, and 49% of case groups and 23% of controls.
Only two of three cases with severe and less than half of cases with moderate metabolic acidaemia were preceded by ST events coinciding with CTG abnormalities. It is therefore important to intervene for long-lasting, rapidly deteriorating or marked (preterminal) CTG abnormalities, also in the absence of ST events.
评估出生时酸血症之前胎儿心电图(ECG)的ST段变化及产时胎心监护(CTG)异常的发生情况。
病例对照研究。
大学医院产房。
重度脐动脉代谢性酸血症(pH<7.00且乳酸≥10 mmol/L;n = 24)、中度代谢性酸血症(pH 7.00 - 7.09且乳酸≥10;n = 48)、酸血症(pH 7.00 - 7.09;n = 52)、酸血症前期(pH 7.10 - 7.19;n = 265)的新生儿,以及对照组(pH≥7.20;n = 117)。
对监测结果进行盲法评估。
CTG和ST段变化。
重度(79%)和中度(75%)代谢性酸血症病例中发生任何ST段事件的频率显著高于对照组(50%)。这种差异仅限于基线T/QRS升高以及第二产程,在此期间,仅重度代谢性酸血症病例中发生任何事件的频率显著高于对照组(62%对38%)。在重度和中度代谢性酸血症、酸血症及酸血症前期病例中,分别有67%、44%、40%和28%的ST段事件与CTG异常模式同时出现,而对照组中这一比例为12%。伴有中间型CTG的ST段事件在病例组(0 - 6%)和对照组(4%)中的发生频率相似。ST段指南规定在96%、62%、73%和49%的病例组以及23%的对照组中进行干预。
重度代谢性酸血症病例中三分之二以及中度代谢性酸血症病例中不到一半在发生ST段事件的同时伴有CTG异常。因此,即使没有ST段事件,对持续时间长、迅速恶化或明显(临危前)的CTG异常进行干预也很重要。