Demelash B, Inangolet F, Oloya J, Asseged B, Badaso M, Yilkal A, Skjerve E
Department of Food Safety and Infection Biology, Centre for Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Norwegian School of Veterinary Science, Oslo, Norway.
Trop Anim Health Prod. 2009 Jun;41(5):755-65. doi: 10.1007/s11250-008-9248-9. Epub 2008 Dec 5.
A study aimed at describing the magnitude and distribution of gross lesions compatible with bovine tuberculosis (BTB) in Ethiiopian slaughter cattle in five abattoirs (four municipal and one export) located in various cattle husbandry systems in Ethiopia was carried out from July 2006 to January 2007 using detailed meat inspection procedure. Five representative abattoirs (four municipal and one export) located in distinct livestock management systems were selected. A total of 3322 cattle; 2876 (86.6%) male, 446 (13.4%) female; 3094 (93.1%) indigenous zebu, 140 (4.2%) crossbred and 88 (2.7%) pure exotic cattle were included in the study. A nine-year meat inspection record was also analyzed to elucidate the trend of BTB in the local cattle population.Of the carcasses inspected, 337 (10.2%, 95%CI= [9.2-11.2]) had lesions suggestive of tuberculosis, 69 (20.5%) generalized and 268 (79.5%) localized.TB prevalence showed a marked variation between categories of age, breed, class of animals, abattoir, geographic origin and husbandry system. It was higher in old and young animals than middle age group; in exotic than local breed; in calves than other classes of animals. The highest and lowest prevalence of TB was recorded in Adama (24.7%, 95%CI= [21.1-28.7]) and Yabello abattoirs (4.2%, 95%CI= [2.6-6.6]), respectively. Cattle whose origin was from Addis Ababa and its surrounding areas had higher prevalence of TB infection (23.9%, 95%CI= [17.6-31.5]).Cattle maintained in dairy farms had high degree of exposure (23.9%, 95%CI= [16.7-32.9]) to the infection than those maintained in other types of management system. Analysis of meat inspection records also revealed an increasing incidence of TB over the years. Our study demonstrated a high prevalence of tuberculosis in Ethiopian slaughter cattle and this could infer to similar scenario in a reference cattle population in the country. In view of Ethiopia's increasing involvement in livestock export trade, the reported high prevalence of tuberculosis could be a major obstacle, particularly at this moment when sanitary requirements from importing countries are so much strict. Furthermore, the growing concern over increasing incidence of tuberculosis/HIV/AIDS co-infection, the high incidence of extra- pulmonary tuberculosis and a high risk of acquiring zoonotic tuberculosis among the majority of the population emphasize the need for paying the necessary attention towards the control of bovine tuberculosis.
2006年7月至2007年1月,采用详细的肉类检验程序,对埃塞俄比亚五个屠宰场(四个市营屠宰场和一个出口屠宰场)的屠宰牛中与牛结核病(BTB)相符的大体病变的严重程度和分布情况进行了研究,这些屠宰场位于埃塞俄比亚不同的畜牧系统中。选择了位于不同畜牧管理系统中的五个有代表性的屠宰场(四个市营屠宰场和一个出口屠宰场)。共有3322头牛被纳入研究,其中2876头(86.6%)为雄性,446头(13.4%)为雌性;3094头(93.1%)为本地瘤牛,140头(4.2%)为杂交牛,88头(2.7%)为纯种外来牛。还分析了一份九年的肉类检验记录,以阐明当地牛群中牛结核病的发展趋势。在检查的胴体中,337头(10.2%,95%置信区间=[9.2-11.2])有提示结核病的病变,69头(20.5%)为全身性病变,268头(79.5%)为局部性病变。结核病患病率在年龄、品种、动物类别、屠宰场、地理来源和畜牧系统类别之间存在显著差异。老龄和幼龄动物的患病率高于中年组;外来品种高于本地品种;犊牛高于其他动物类别。结核病患病率最高和最低的分别是阿达马屠宰场(24.7%,95%置信区间=[21.1-28.7])和亚贝洛屠宰场(4.2%,95%置信区间=[2.6-6.6])。来自亚的斯亚贝巴及其周边地区的牛结核病感染患病率较高(23.9%,95%置信区间=[17.6-31.5])。与其他类型管理系统中的牛相比,奶牛场饲养的牛感染该疾病的暴露程度较高(23.9%,95%置信区间=[16.7-32.9])。对肉类检验记录的分析还显示,多年来结核病发病率呈上升趋势。我们的研究表明,埃塞俄比亚屠宰牛中结核病患病率很高,这可能意味着该国参考牛群中也存在类似情况。鉴于埃塞俄比亚越来越多地参与牲畜出口贸易,报告的高结核病患病率可能是一个主要障碍,特别是在进口国卫生要求如此严格的当下。此外,对结核病/艾滋病毒/艾滋病合并感染发病率上升、肺外结核病高发病率以及大多数人群中获得人畜共患结核病高风险的日益关注,强调了有必要对牛结核病的控制给予必要关注。