Jen Min Hua, Jones Kelvyn, Johnston Ron
Department of Primary Care and Social Medicine, Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom.
Soc Sci Med. 2009 Feb;68(4):643-53. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2008.11.026. Epub 2008 Dec 16.
This international comparative study analyses individual-level data derived from the World Values Survey to evaluate Wilkinson's [(1996). Unhealthy societies: The afflictions of inequality. London: Routledge; (1998). Mortality and distribution of income. Low relative income affects mortality [letter; comment]. British Medical Journal, 316, 1611-1612] income inequality hypothesis regarding variations in health status. Random-coefficient, multilevel modelling provides a direct test of Wilkinson's hypothesis using micro-data on individuals and macro-data on income inequalities analysed simultaneously. This overcomes the ecological fallacy that has troubled previous research into links between individual self-rated health, individual income, country income and income inequality data. Logic regression analysis reveals that there are substantial differences between countries in self-rated health after taking account of age and gender, and individual income has a clear effect in that poorer people report experiencing worse health. The Wilkinson hypothesis is not supported, however, since there is no significant relationship between health and income inequality when individual factors are taken into account. Substantial differences between countries remain even after taking account of micro- and macro-variables; in particular the former communist countries report high levels of poor health.
这项国际比较研究分析了来自世界价值观调查的个人层面数据,以评估威尔金森[(1996年)。不健康的社会:不平等的折磨。伦敦:劳特利奇出版社;(1998年)。死亡率与收入分配。低相对收入影响死亡率[信件;评论]关于健康状况差异的收入不平等假说。随机系数多层模型使用关于个人的微观数据和同时分析的关于收入不平等的宏观数据,对威尔金森假说进行了直接检验。这克服了困扰先前关于个人自评健康、个人收入、国家收入和收入不平等数据之间联系研究的生态谬误。逻辑回归分析表明,在考虑年龄和性别后,各国在自评健康方面存在显著差异,而且个人收入有明显影响,即较贫穷的人报告健康状况较差。然而,威尔金森假说未得到支持,因为在考虑个人因素后,健康与收入不平等之间没有显著关系。即使考虑了微观和宏观变量,各国之间仍存在显著差异;特别是前共产主义国家报告了较高水平的健康不佳情况。