Caristo Elisa, Parola Andrea, Rapa Anna, Vivenza Daniela, Raselli Barbara, Dondi Elena, Boldorini Renzo, Oderda Giuseppina
Department of Pediatrics, Università del Piemonte Orientale, Novara, Italy.
Helicobacter. 2008 Dec;13(6):557-63. doi: 10.1111/j.1523-5378.2008.00642.x.
To assess validity of culture on four-sector agar plates and fluorescent in-situ hybridization (FISH) test, and clarithromycin resistance rate in Helicobacter pylori strains isolated from children in the last 10 years.
In the last 5 years, gastric biopsy specimens from antrum and fundus were taken from 89 consecutive children (median age 9 years) with H. pylori gastritis and from 21 controls. Culture was performed on 176 gastric biopsies (89 from antrum, 87 from fundus) on four-sector agar plates, and FISH test with DNA ProbeMix. After its validity was evaluated, FISH test was applied on additional 119 biopsies from 68 children (68 from the antrum, 51 from the fundus) stored in the Pathology archive in the previous 5 years.
Culture was positive in 157 of 176 biopsies (sensitivity: 89.2%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 85-94). In 33 of 89 children (37%) resistant strains were found in one or both gastric sites. FISH test was positive in 148 of 176 biopsies from infected children (sensitivity 84.1%, 95%CI 79-89) and in none of 42 biopsies from controls (specificity 100%). When applied on archive biopsies, FISH test was positive in 96 of 119 (80.7%, 95%CI 74-88). Total children harboring resistant strains in the last 10 years, as assessed by FISH test, were 66 of 157 (42%). Mixed infection with both sensitive and resistant strains were found in 40 children (25%) and in 12 of them resistant strains were in the fundus only.
Culture on four-sector agar plates and FISH test had a high sensitivity and specificity and showed co-presence of sensitive and resistant strains. In one-third of children with mixed infection, the resistant strains were in the fundus only. Clarithromycin resistance should be assessed in biopsies both from the antrum and the fundus, utilizing antral biopsies only can underestimate its prevalence.
评估四区琼脂平板培养和荧光原位杂交(FISH)检测的有效性,以及过去10年从儿童中分离出的幽门螺杆菌菌株的克拉霉素耐药率。
在过去5年中,对89例连续的幽门螺杆菌胃炎患儿(中位年龄9岁)和21例对照儿童进行胃窦和胃底的胃活检标本采集。对176份胃活检标本(89份来自胃窦,87份来自胃底)在四区琼脂平板上进行培养,并用DNA探针混合物进行FISH检测。在评估其有效性后,对过去5年保存在病理档案中的68例儿童的另外119份活检标本(68份来自胃窦,51份来自胃底)进行FISH检测。
176份活检标本中有157份培养阳性(敏感性:89.2%,95%置信区间(CI)85 - 94)。在89例儿童中的33例(37%),在一个或两个胃部位发现了耐药菌株。FISH检测在176份感染儿童的活检标本中有148份呈阳性(敏感性84.1%,95%CI 79 - 89),而42份对照活检标本均为阴性(特异性100%)。当应用于存档活检标本时,FISH检测在119份中有96份呈阳性(80.7%,95%CI 74 - 88)。通过FISH检测评估,过去10年中携带耐药菌株的儿童总数为157例中的66例(42%)。在40例儿童(25%)中发现了敏感菌株和耐药菌株的混合感染,其中12例的耐药菌株仅存在于胃底。
四区琼脂平板培养和FISH检测具有较高的敏感性和特异性,并显示出敏感菌株和耐药菌株的共存。在三分之一的混合感染儿童中,耐药菌株仅存在于胃底。应同时对胃窦和胃底的活检标本进行克拉霉素耐药性评估,仅使用胃窦活检标本会低估其患病率。