Claude Bernard University, Lyon 1, CRIS EA 647, Laboratory of Motor, Mental and Material Performance, Villeurbanne, France.
Appl Ergon. 2009 Nov;40(6):1041-6. doi: 10.1016/j.apergo.2009.01.007. Epub 2009 Feb 26.
Sharing attention between two tasks requiring the same mental resources is supposed to increase the resulting strain. Phoning while driving may elicit cognitive interference between driving operations and conversation and consequently, may affect driving efficiency. The road scene cues may thus be perceived late or even omitted, increasing the probability to be involved in a critical situation. The aim of the experiment was to study how the additional strain elicited by a secondary task may change drivers' arousal with potential consequences on driving performance. Electrodermal activity, heart rate and reaction time (RT) were the dependent variables. Listening to the radio, holding an in-vehicle or a cell-phone conversation were the secondary communication tasks, performed by 10 participants during a driving sequence on a private circuit. Within nominal driving, each communication task was requested at random to prevent any habituation or anticipation. The cell-phone conversation made RT increase by about 20%, by comparison to the nominal driving condition. Nevertheless, the in-vehicle conversation impacted RT almost in the same proportion. Physiological data showed that arousal level increased as a function of dual-tasks requirements, the in-vehicle conversation eliciting the same strain as the remote conversation. With caution due to contextual differences between these two communication tasks, conversing with a passenger was thus as detrimental as using a cell-phone.
在两个需要相同心理资源的任务之间分配注意力,预计会增加由此产生的压力。边开车边打电话可能会在驾驶操作和对话之间产生认知干扰,从而影响驾驶效率。道路场景线索可能因此被延迟感知,甚至被忽略,增加了陷入危险情况的可能性。实验的目的是研究次要任务引起的额外压力如何改变驾驶员的警觉性,以及这可能对驾驶表现产生的潜在影响。皮肤电活动、心率和反应时间(RT)是因变量。听广播、使用车内或手机通话是 10 名参与者在私人赛道上的驾驶序列中进行的次要交流任务。在名义驾驶中,每个通信任务都是随机请求的,以防止任何习惯化或预期。与名义驾驶条件相比,手机通话使 RT 增加了约 20%。然而,车内通话对 RT 的影响几乎相同。生理数据表明,唤醒水平随双重任务要求而增加,车内通话引起的压力与远程通话相同。由于这两个通信任务之间的背景差异,需要谨慎对待,与乘客交谈与使用手机一样有害。