de Heus Roel, Mol Ben Willem, Erwich Jan-Jaap H M, van Geijn Herman P, Gyselaers Wilfried J, Hanssens Myriam, Härmark Linda, van Holsbeke Caroline D, Duvekot Johannes J, Schobben Fred F A M, Wolf Hans, Visser Gerard H A
Department of Perinatology and Gynaecology, University Medical Centre Utrecht, KJ.02.507.0/PO Box 85090, Utrecht, Netherlands.
BMJ. 2009 Mar 5;338:b744. doi: 10.1136/bmj.b744.
To evaluate the incidence of serious maternal complications after the use of various tocolytic drugs for the treatment of preterm labour in routine clinical situations.
Prospective cohort study.
28 hospitals in the Netherlands and Belgium.
1920 consecutive women treated with tocolytics for threatened preterm labour.
Maternal adverse events (those suspected of being causally related to treatment were considered adverse drug reactions) leading to cessation of treatment.
An independent panel evaluated the recorded adverse events, without knowledge of the type of tocolytic used. Of the 1920 women treated with tocolytics, 1327 received a single course of treatment (69.1%), 282 sequential courses (14.7%), and 311 combined courses (16.2%). Adverse drug reactions were categorised as serious or mild in 14 cases each. The overall incidence of serious adverse drug reaction was 0.7%. Compared with atosiban, the relative risk of an adverse drug reaction for single treatment with a beta adrenoceptor agonist was 22.0 (95% confidence interval 3.6 to 138.0) and for single treatment with a calcium antagonist was 12 (1.9 to 69). Multiple drug tocolysis led to five serious adverse drug reactions (1.6%). Multiple gestation, preterm rupture of membranes, and comorbidity were not independent risk factors for adverse drug reactions.
The use of beta adrenoceptor agonists or multiple tocolytics for preventing preterm birth is associated with a high incidence of serious adverse drug reactions. Indometacin and atosiban were the only drugs not associated with serious adverse drug reactions. A direct comparison of the effectiveness of nifedipine and atosiban in postponing preterm delivery is needed.
评估在常规临床情况下使用各种宫缩抑制剂治疗早产时严重母体并发症的发生率。
前瞻性队列研究。
荷兰和比利时的28家医院。
1920例连续接受宫缩抑制剂治疗先兆早产的妇女。
导致治疗中断的母体不良事件(那些怀疑与治疗有因果关系的被视为药物不良反应)。
一个独立小组在不知道所使用宫缩抑制剂类型的情况下评估记录的不良事件。在1920例接受宫缩抑制剂治疗的妇女中,1327例接受单一疗程治疗(69.1%),282例接受序贯疗程治疗(14.7%),311例接受联合疗程治疗(16.2%)。药物不良反应分为严重或轻度,各有14例。严重药物不良反应的总体发生率为0.7%。与阿托西班相比,单用β肾上腺素能受体激动剂发生药物不良反应的相对风险为22.0(95%置信区间3.6至138.0),单用钙拮抗剂为12(1.9至69)。多种药物联合抑制宫缩导致5例严重药物不良反应(1.6%)。多胎妊娠、胎膜早破和合并症不是药物不良反应的独立危险因素。
使用β肾上腺素能受体激动剂或多种宫缩抑制剂预防早产与严重药物不良反应的高发生率相关。吲哚美辛和阿托西班是仅与严重药物不良反应无关的药物。需要直接比较硝苯地平和阿托西班在推迟早产方面的有效性。