Lawton Julia, Rankin David, Peel Elizabeth, Douglas Margaret
Centre for Population Health Sciences, Community Health Sciences, The University of Edinburgh Medical School, UK.
Health Expect. 2009 Jun;12(2):138-48. doi: 10.1111/j.1369-7625.2009.00537.x. Epub 2009 Mar 20.
To examine patients' perceptions and experiences over time of the devolvement of diabetes care/reviews from secondary to primary health-care settings.
Repeat in-depth interviews with 20 patients over 4 years.
Twenty type 2 diabetes patients recruited from primary- and secondary-care settings across Lothian, Scotland.
Patients' views about their current diabetes care were informed by their previous service contact. The devolvement of diabetes care/reviews to general practice was presented as a 'mixed blessing'. Patients gained reassurance from their perception that receiving practice-based care/reviews signified that their diabetes was well-controlled. However, they also expressed resentment that, by achieving good control, they received what they saw as inferior care and/or less-frequent reviews to others with poorer control. While patients tended to regard GPs as having adequate expertise to conduct their practice-based reviews, they were more ambivalent about nurses taking on this role. Opportunities to receive holistic care in general practice were not always realized due to patients seeing health-care professionals for diabetes management to whom they would not normally present for other health issues.
It is important to educate patients about their care pathways, and to reassure them that frequency of reviews depends more on clinical need than location of care and that similar care guidelines are followed in hospital clinics and general practice. A patients' history of service contact may need to be taken into account in future studies of service satisfaction.
探讨患者对糖尿病护理/复查从二级医疗保健机构向初级医疗保健机构移交的看法及长期以来的体验。
4年内对20名患者进行重复深入访谈。
从苏格兰洛锡安地区的初级和二级医疗保健机构招募的20名2型糖尿病患者。
患者对当前糖尿病护理的看法受其之前就医经历的影响。糖尿病护理/复查向全科医疗的移交被视为“喜忧参半”。患者因认为接受基于全科医疗的护理/复查表明其糖尿病得到良好控制而感到安心。然而,他们也表示不满,因为通过实现良好控制,他们得到的护理在他们看来不如控制较差的患者,且复查频率较低。虽然患者倾向于认为全科医生有足够的专业知识进行基于全科医疗的复查,但他们对护士承担这一角色则较为矛盾。由于患者因糖尿病管理去看医疗保健专业人员,而这些专业人员通常不是他们因其他健康问题会去就诊的对象,所以在全科医疗中获得整体护理的机会并不总是能实现。
对患者进行护理途径方面的教育很重要,并向他们保证复查频率更多地取决于临床需求而非护理地点,且医院诊所和全科医疗遵循相似的护理指南。在未来的服务满意度研究中可能需要考虑患者的就医经历。