Alvaran Natalia, Roldan Samuel I, Buschang Peter H
Department of Orthodontics, CES University, Medellín, Colombia.
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2009 May;135(5):649-56. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2007.05.023.
This study provides reference data and evaluates the potential of using regression models to predict maxillary and mandibular arch widths.
A total of 473 Colombian mestizos, aged 5 to 17 years, with normal occlusions and malocclusions (Class I and Class II Division 1) were evaluated. Arch widths and tooth sizes were measured on each subject's dental casts. Anthropometric measurements of body size, facial breadth, and facial height were used, along with tooth sizes, to develop multiple regressions for predicting arch widths.
Analyses showed that Class II subjects had significantly (P < 0.05) narrower anterior maxillary widths than those with normal occlusion or Class I malocclusion. Class I subjects had narrower interpremolar widths than those with normal occlusion or Class II malocclusion. Boys had significantly (P < 0.001) wider arches than girls, especially in the posterior aspects. Older children had significantly wider arches than younger children, with intermolar and interpremolar widths having the largest and smallest age effects, respectively. Regression analyses of subjects with normal occlusion showed that 2 to 5 variables combined to explain 36% to 64% of the variation in arch widths, with the sizes of the maxillary incisors and bigonial width explaining most of the variation.
When applied to subjects with malocclusion, the predictions indicate transverse deficiencies in the premolar region of Class I subjects and deficiencies in the anterior maxilla of Class II subjects. Predictions based on Pont's index, the Schwarz analysis, or the McNamara rule of thumb were biased and less reliable than those based on the regressions.
本研究提供参考数据,并评估使用回归模型预测上颌和下颌牙弓宽度的潜力。
对473名年龄在5至17岁之间、具有正常咬合和错牙合(I类和II类1分类)的哥伦比亚混血儿进行了评估。在每个受试者的石膏模型上测量牙弓宽度和牙齿大小。使用身体尺寸、面部宽度和面部高度的人体测量数据以及牙齿大小来建立预测牙弓宽度的多元回归模型。
分析表明,II类受试者的上颌前部宽度明显(P < 0.05)比正常咬合或I类错牙合受试者窄。I类受试者的前磨牙间宽度比正常咬合或II类错牙合受试者窄。男孩的牙弓明显(P < 0.001)比女孩宽,尤其是在后部。年龄较大的儿童的牙弓比年龄较小的儿童宽,磨牙间和前磨牙间宽度受年龄的影响分别最大和最小。对正常咬合受试者的回归分析表明,2至5个变量组合起来可解释牙弓宽度变化的36%至64%,其中上颌切牙大小和下颌角宽度解释了大部分变化。
当应用于错牙合受试者时,预测结果表明I类受试者前磨牙区域存在横向不足,II类受试者上颌前部存在不足。基于庞特指数、施瓦茨分析或麦克纳马拉经验法则的预测存在偏差,且不如基于回归分析的预测可靠。