Knapp Peter, Raynor David K, Thistlethwaite Jill E, Jones Marc B
School of Healthcare, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Health Expect. 2009 Jun;12(2):175-86. doi: 10.1111/j.1369-7625.2009.00545.x.
To revise and improve an existing scale to measure health practitioners' attitudes to partnership in medicine taking and to ascertain the views of medical students, nursing students and pre-registration pharmacists on concordance.
The traditional model of the practitioner-patient interaction incorporates a practitioner-centred approach, focusing on the disease rather than the patient. The philosophy of 'concordance' (or 'partnership in medicine-taking') puts the patient at the centre of the interaction, with the patient interacting reciprocally with the practitioner. The Leeds Attitude to Concordance (LATCon) scale was developed in 2001 to assess practitioners' and patients' attitudes to concordance. However, thinking on concordance has developed since then and the present study aimed to revise the scale to ensure that it reflected current thinking and also to increase its reliability and validity.
A pool of potential items was developed and sent to three subject experts for opinion. An attitudinal Likert scale of 31 items was developed. Its completion was followed by statistical item reduction to 20 items. The shorter scale was completed by the same participants 4-6 weeks later.
The study was set in a university in the UK. Participants were 183 medical students, nursing students, and pre-registration pharmacists.
The study derived a 20 item scale, including five negatively-worded items, with good levels of internal and test-retest reliability. Factor analysis suggested five main factors. A statistically significant difference in attitudes was found between student nurses and medical students, and student nurses and pre-registration pharmacists, with student nurses being more in agreement with the concordant approach. Overall, participants were in agreement with the concordant approach to medicine taking. The UK National Health Service advocates partnership in medical care and is encouraging both practitioners and patients to work to introduce this. There is increased awareness of the patients' perspective by practitioners, but its impact on their practice remains unclear. Education and skills teaching must continue for the benefits of a concordant approach to be seen. The LATCon scale could play a useful role in education and training, and in research assessing the movement towards the new approach.
修订并改进现有的用于衡量医疗从业者对共同参与药物治疗态度的量表,并确定医学生、护理专业学生和预注册药剂师对一致性的看法。
传统的医患互动模式采用以从业者为中心的方法,关注疾病而非患者。“一致性”(或“共同参与药物治疗”)理念将患者置于互动的中心,患者与从业者相互交流。利兹一致性态度(LATCon)量表于2001年开发,用于评估从业者和患者对一致性的态度。然而,自那时以来,关于一致性的观念有所发展,本研究旨在修订该量表,以确保其反映当前的观念,并提高其信度和效度。
制定了一系列潜在条目并发送给三位专家征求意见。开发了一个包含31个条目的态度李克特量表。完成该量表后进行统计项目缩减至20个条目。4至6周后,相同的参与者完成了较短的量表。
该研究在英国一所大学进行。参与者为183名医学生、护理专业学生和预注册药剂师。
该研究得出了一个包含20个条目的量表,其中包括5个反向计分条目,具有良好的内部一致性和重测信度。因子分析表明有五个主要因素。发现护理专业学生与医学生之间以及护理专业学生与预注册药剂师之间在态度上存在统计学显著差异,护理专业学生更认同一致性方法。总体而言,参与者认同共同参与药物治疗的方法。英国国民医疗服务体系提倡医疗护理中的合作关系,并鼓励从业者和患者共同努力引入这种关系。从业者对患者观点的认识有所提高,但其对实践产生的影响仍不明确。为了看到一致性方法的益处,必须继续进行教育和技能教学。LATCon量表在教育和培训以及评估向新方法转变的研究中可以发挥有益作用。