Hersberger K E, Botomino A, Sarkar R, Tschudi P, Bucher H C, Briel M
Institute of Clinical Pharmacy, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland.
J Clin Pharm Ther. 2009 Aug;34(4):387-95. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2710.2009.01049.x.
Symptomatic medications are often not considered in clinical studies assessing interventions to reduce prescribing of antibiotics for acute respiratory tract infections (ARTI). Our study objectives were to examine prescribing patterns of antibiotics and symptomatic medications for ARTI in Swiss primary care and to monitor pharmacists' interventions during the prescription-dispensing process.
Medical records of 695 patients participating in a clinical trial which was designed to reduce use of antibiotics for ARTI in primary care, were linked to their prescriptions. Matching of prescribed and dispensed medications enabled the assessment of interventions by community pharmacists.
On average, 2.4 different drugs were prescribed per patient (in total 142 antibiotics, 1599 symptomatic medications, and 56 non-ARTI-medication). Most patients (80%) were treated only with symptomatic medications. Most frequently prescribed symptomatic ARTI-medications were nasal decongestants (39%), cough suppressants (36%), and mucolytics (31%). Patients with prescribed antibiotics received significantly fewer symptomatic medications (odds ratio, 0.24; 95% confidence interval 0.16-0.37). Over 20% of prescriptions prompted at least one intervention by a pharmacist in the dispensing process. A discrepancy between prescribed and dispensed medications was seen in 19% of patients.
Prescription rates of antibiotics for ARTI in this trial were low and patients were treated mainly with non-antibiotic symptomatic medications. Efforts to reduce antibiotic prescribing may induce higher rates of use of medications for intensive symptomatic treatment. Considerable differences between prescribed and dispensed medications were noted.
在评估减少急性呼吸道感染(ARTI)抗生素处方干预措施的临床研究中,往往未考虑对症药物。我们的研究目的是调查瑞士初级医疗中ARTI的抗生素和对症药物处方模式,并监测配药过程中药剂师的干预情况。
将695名参与旨在减少初级医疗中ARTI抗生素使用的临床试验患者的病历与其处方相关联。通过匹配处方药物和配药,能够评估社区药剂师的干预情况。
每位患者平均开具2.4种不同药物(总计142种抗生素、1599种对症药物和56种非ARTI药物)。大多数患者(80%)仅接受对症药物治疗。最常开具的ARTI对症药物是减充血剂(39%)、止咳药(36%)和黏液溶解剂(31%)。开具了抗生素的患者接受的对症药物显著较少(优势比为0.24;95%置信区间为0.16 - 0.37)。超过20%的处方在配药过程中促使药剂师至少进行了一次干预。19%的患者出现了处方药物与配药不符的情况。
该试验中ARTI的抗生素处方率较低,患者主要接受非抗生素对症药物治疗。减少抗生素处方的努力可能会导致强化对症治疗药物的使用率上升。注意到处方药物与配药之间存在相当大的差异。