Metaxas Thomas I, Koutlianos Nikos, Sendelides Thomas, Mandroukas Athanasios
Department of Physical Education and Sports Sciences, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Laboratory of Ergophysioloy-Ergometry, Thessaloniki, Greece.
J Strength Cond Res. 2009 Sep;23(6):1704-13. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0b013e3181b3e0c5.
The purpose of this study was to examine and compare the cardiorespiratory performance and isokinetic muscle strength between Greek soccer and basketball players of different divisions before starting the training season. Study participants included 100 soccer players and 61 basketball players, who were assigned according to the kind of sport and division. All participants underwent anthropometric measurements and performed an exercise test on a treadmill to determine maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max). Peak torque for quadriceps and hamstring muscles was measured on isokinetic dynamometer at angular velocity of 60 degrees/s(-1), 180 degrees/s(-1), and 300 degrees/s(-1). The statistical p value was set at p < 0.05. In soccer players VO2max in absolute and relative values was significantly lower in division IV compared to the other 3 divisions (3,413.4 +/- 351.0 vs. 3,932.7 +/- 551.2, 4,172.7 +/- 371.8, 4,223.0 +/- 323.8 ml x min(-1), respectively; p < 0.001 and 46.93 +/- 4.20 vs. 52.47 +/- 3.66, 54.86 +/- 3.80, 55.32 +/- 3.33 ml x kg x min(-1), respectively; p < 0.001). Basketball players presented significantly higher VO2max, in absolute values, compared to soccer players for divisions II (4,586.3 +/- 586.3 vs. 4,172.7 +/- 371.8 ml x min(-1); p < 0.05), III (4,319.6 +/- 418.6 vs. 3,932.7 +/- 551.2 ml x min(-1); p < 0.01), and IV (4,624.0 +/- 627.6 vs. 3,413.4 +/- 351.0 ml x min(-1); p < 0.001), respectively. Regarding peak torque, only basketball players showed significantly higher values at 60 degrees/sec(-1) in hamstrings for III (p < 0.05) and IV division (p < 0.05). Conclusively, the higher VO2max reached by professional soccer and basketball players compared to semiprofessional and amateur ones and between the soccer and basketball players of the same division can be attributed to the different duration of the maintenance period and to the effect of the training session on each sport, respectively. Finally, a higher level of muscle strength would be preferable in soccer and basketball and would reduce the risk for injuries in the maintenance and rebuilding training periods.
本研究的目的是在训练季开始前,对不同级别希腊足球运动员和篮球运动员的心肺功能及等速肌力进行检测和比较。研究参与者包括100名足球运动员和61名篮球运动员,他们根据运动项目和级别进行分组。所有参与者均接受人体测量,并在跑步机上进行运动测试以确定最大摄氧量(VO2max)。在等速测力计上,以60度/秒(-1)、180度/秒(-1)和300度/秒(-1)的角速度测量股四头肌和腘绳肌的峰值扭矩。统计p值设定为p < 0.05。在足球运动员中,与其他3个级别相比,四级别的VO2max绝对值和相对值均显著更低(分别为3413.4 ± 351.0 vs. 3932.7 ± 551.2、4172.7 ± 371.8、4223.0 ± 323.8毫升/分钟;p < 0.001以及46.93 ± 4.20 vs. 52.47 ± 3.66、54.86 ± 3.80、55.32 ± 3.33毫升/千克/分钟;p < 0.001)。在二级别(4586.3 ± 586.3 vs. 4172.7 ± 371.8毫升/分钟;p < 0.05)、三级别(4319.6 ± 418.6 vs. 3932.7 ± 551.2毫升/分钟;p < 0.01)和四级别(4624.0 ± 627.6 vs. 3413.4 ± 351.0毫升/分钟;p < 0.001)的篮球运动员中,VO2max绝对值相比足球运动员显著更高。关于峰值扭矩,仅篮球运动员在三级别(p < 0.05)和四级别(p < 0.05)的腘绳肌60度/秒(-1)时显示出显著更高的值。结论是,职业足球和篮球运动员相比半职业和业余运动员以及同一级别足球和篮球运动员之间达到的更高VO2max,可分别归因于维持期的不同时长以及各运动训练课的影响。最后,在足球和篮球运动中,更高水平的肌肉力量会更可取,并且会降低维持期和重建训练期受伤的风险。