Department of Infectious and Tropical Diseases, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK.
BMC Public Health. 2009 Oct 15;9:390. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-9-390.
Interventions to increase hand washing in schools have been advocated as a means to reduce the transmission of pandemic influenza and other infections. However, the feasibility and acceptability of effective school-based hygiene interventions is not clear.
A pilot study in four primary schools in East London was conducted to establish the current need for enhanced hand hygiene interventions, identify barriers to their implementation and to test their acceptability and feasibility. The pilot study included key informant interviews with teachers and school nurses, interviews, group discussions and essay questions with the children, and testing of organised classroom hand hygiene activities.
In all schools, basic issues of personal hygiene were taught especially in the younger age groups. However, we identified many barriers to implementing intensive hygiene interventions, in particular time constraints and competing health issues. Teachers' motivation to teach hygiene and enforce hygienic behaviour was primarily educational rather than immediate infection control. Children of all age groups had good knowledge of hygiene practices and germ transmission.
The pilot study showed that intensive hand hygiene interventions are feasible and acceptable but only temporarily during a period of a particular health threat such as an influenza pandemic, and only if rinse-free hand sanitisers are used. However, in many settings there may be logistical issues in providing all schools with an adequate supply. In the absence of evidence on effectiveness, the scope for enhanced hygiene interventions in schools in high income countries aiming at infection control appears to be limited in the absence of a severe public health threat.
提倡在学校中增加洗手干预,以减少大流行性流感和其他感染的传播。然而,基于学校的卫生干预措施的可行性和可接受性尚不清楚。
在东伦敦的四所小学进行了一项试点研究,以确定增强手部卫生干预措施的当前需求,确定实施这些措施的障碍,并检验其可接受性和可行性。该试点研究包括对教师和学校护士进行重点访谈、对儿童进行访谈、小组讨论和论文问题测试、以及组织课堂手部卫生活动的测试。
在所有学校中,都教授了基本的个人卫生问题,尤其是在年龄较小的群体中。但是,我们发现实施强化卫生干预措施存在许多障碍,尤其是时间限制和竞争的健康问题。教师教授卫生和执行卫生行为的动机主要是教育性的,而不是直接的感染控制。所有年龄段的儿童都对卫生习惯和细菌传播有很好的了解。
试点研究表明,密集的手部卫生干预措施是可行且可接受的,但仅在特定的健康威胁期间(如流感大流行)是暂时的,并且只有在使用免冲洗的手部消毒剂时才可行。然而,在许多情况下,为所有学校提供足够供应可能存在后勤问题。在缺乏有效性证据的情况下,在高收入国家,针对感染控制目的的学校强化卫生干预措施的范围似乎受到限制,除非存在严重的公共卫生威胁。