Department of Human Morphology, University of Milan, Milano, Italy.
Angle Orthod. 2009 Nov;79(6):1070-7. doi: 10.2319/111008-570.
To test whether digital photographs supported by three-dimensional (3D) software are suitable for measuring the facial soft tissues of healthy subjects as compared with data obtained by a certified 3D computerized electromagnetic digitizer.
Three-dimensional soft tissue facial landmarks were obtained from the faces of 15 healthy young adults, using a 3D computerized electromagnetic digitizer and a new low-cost photogrammetry system. Twelve linear and 18 angular measurements were computed. Errors between methods and repeatability of the new method were calculated.
Systematic errors between methods were found for only two distances and three angles (paired t-test, P < .05). The mean absolute differences between methods were always lower than 3 mm and 3 degrees. Repeated digitization of photographs showed that the method was repeatable (no systematic differences; random errors lower than 1.6 mm and 3 degrees). Repeated sets of photographs showed random errors of up to 5.3 mm and 5.6 degrees, without systematic biases.
The 3D photogrammetry system can provide reliable facial measurements. The method is relatively fast and requires only inexpensive equipment. It is simple to use for private practice, research, or other practice.
测试通过三维(3D)软件支持的数字照片是否适合测量健康受试者的面部软组织,与使用经过认证的 3D 计算机电磁数字化仪获得的数据相比。
使用 3D 计算机电磁数字化仪和新的低成本摄影测量系统,从 15 名健康年轻成年人的面部获取三维软组织面部标志。计算了 12 个线性和 18 个角度测量值。计算了两种方法之间的误差和新方法的可重复性。
仅在两个距离和三个角度(配对 t 检验,P <.05)之间发现了方法之间的系统误差。方法之间的平均绝对差异始终低于 3 毫米和 3 度。对照片的重复数字化表明该方法具有可重复性(无系统差异;随机误差低于 1.6 毫米和 3 度)。重复的照片集显示随机误差最大可达 5.3 毫米和 5.6 度,没有系统偏差。
3D 摄影测量系统可以提供可靠的面部测量。该方法相对较快,只需要廉价的设备。它易于在私人诊所、研究或其他实践中使用。