Nadler Evan P, Brotman Laurie M, Miyoshi Thomas, Fryer George E, Weitzman Michael
Division of Pediatric Surgery, New York University School of Medicine, New York, NY 10016, USA.
J Pediatr Surg. 2009 Oct;44(10):1869-76. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2008.12.033.
Some have suggested that the criteria for weight loss surgery in adolescents be stricter than those currently recommended for adults by the National Institutes of Health (NIH). The aim of the current study is to define the characteristics of adolescents who meet NIH consensus criteria for bariatric surgery in adults to determine their level of morbidity.
Using the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey 2000-2004, children designated as meeting NIH criteria were 13 to 17 years of age with (1) a body mass index >or=40 or (2) a body mass index >35, and one or more comorbidity. We contrasted surgery candidates with noncandidates. We examined items that comprise a screener for identifying children with special health care needs. The Columbia Impairment Scale (CIS) was used to assess child functioning.
There were 134 children identified as candidates for bariatric surgery and 4736 noncandidates in the same age range. Candidates were more likely to have special health care needs (36% vs 23%) and more likely to have a CIS above 16 (34% vs 16%). Candidates for weight loss surgery were 2.36 times as likely to have a CIS score of 16 or higher and 1.87 times as likely to be identified as a child with special health care needs (P <or= .001).
We conclude that adolescents who meet NIH consensus criteria for weight loss surgery in adults require specialized health services and have functional impairment. Thus, we advocate the use of the standard adult criteria defined by the NIH as the initial screening requirements so that enhanced access to weight loss surgery for morbidly obese adolescents may be achieved.
一些人认为,青少年减肥手术的标准应比美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)目前为成年人推荐的标准更为严格。本研究的目的是确定符合NIH成人减肥手术共识标准的青少年的特征,以确定他们的发病水平。
利用2000 - 2004年医疗支出小组调查,被认定符合NIH标准的儿童年龄在13至17岁之间,(1)体重指数≥40,或(2)体重指数>35,且有一种或多种合并症。我们将手术候选者与非候选者进行了对比。我们检查了用于识别有特殊医疗需求儿童的筛查项目。采用哥伦比亚损伤量表(CIS)评估儿童的功能。
在同一年龄范围内,有134名儿童被确定为减肥手术候选者,4736名儿童为非候选者。候选者更有可能有特殊医疗需求(36%对23%),且CIS得分高于16的可能性更大(34%对16%)。减肥手术候选者CIS得分达到16或更高的可能性是普通儿童的2.36倍,被认定为有特殊医疗需求儿童的可能性是普通儿童的1.87倍(P≤0.001)。
我们得出结论,符合NIH成人减肥手术共识标准的青少年需要专门的医疗服务,且存在功能障碍。因此,我们主张将NIH定义的成人标准作为初始筛查要求,以便为病态肥胖青少年增加减肥手术的可及性。