Globalisation/Health Equity, Institute of Population Health, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 2010 Jun;64(6):488-94. doi: 10.1136/jech.2008.086249. Epub 2009 Oct 23.
Indigenous populations tend to have the poorest health outcomes worldwide and they have limited opportunities to present their own perspectives of their situation and shape priorities in research and policy. This study aims to explain low healthcare utilisation rates and opportunities to cope with illness among a deprived indigenous group - based on their own experiences and views.
A participatory poverty and health assessment (PPHA) was conducted among the Paniyas, a previously enslaved tribal population of South India in a Gram Panchayat in Kerala, India in 2008. Purposive sampling was used to select five Paniya colonies, involving 66 households.
There were four key findings. First, Paniyas' perception that the quality of the public healthcare system is poor leads them to seek suboptimal care or deters them from using services. Second, there are significant costs of care unrelated to service use or purchase of medicines, such as travel costs, which the Paniyas lack the ability to pay. Third, illness can lead to loss of productive opportunities among those who fall ill and those who provide informal care. Fourth, the Paniyas lack a 'range' of coping strategies as they are wage labourers without diverse sources of income. They rely on a single strategy: borrowing from outside their community, often from landowners and employers, to whom they become indebted with their labour.
Improving the capacity of tribal populations to present their own perspectives is likely to lead to more effective tribal development policies and consequently better health.
世界各地的土著居民往往拥有最差的健康状况,他们几乎没有机会表达自己对现状的看法,也无法在研究和政策中确定优先事项。本研究旨在根据一个贫困的土著群体的自身经历和观点,解释其医疗保健利用率低和应对疾病的机会有限的原因。
2008 年,在印度喀拉拉邦的一个 Gram Panchayat,对印度南部一个曾经被奴役的部落群体——帕尼亚人进行了参与式贫困和健康评估(PPHA)。采用目的抽样法选择了五个帕尼亚人聚居地,涉及 66 户家庭。
有四个主要发现。首先,帕尼亚人认为公共医疗体系质量差,这导致他们寻求次优的医疗服务,或阻止他们使用医疗服务。其次,存在与服务使用或购买药物无关的大量医疗费用,例如,出行成本,而帕尼亚人无力支付这些费用。第三,疾病可能导致生病者和提供非正式护理者失去生产性机会。第四,帕尼亚人缺乏“应对策略范围”,因为他们是没有多种收入来源的雇佣劳动者。他们依赖于单一的策略:向社区外借款,通常是向地主和雇主借款,并用劳动来偿还债务。
提高部落群体表达自身观点的能力,可能会导致更有效的部落发展政策,并最终改善健康状况。