Incorvaia Cristoforo, Mauro Marina, Ridolo Erminia, Puccinelli Paola, Liuzzo Massimiliano, Scurati Silvia, Frati Franco
Allergy/Pulmonary rehabilitation Unit, ICP Hospital, Milan, Italy.
Patient Prefer Adherence. 2008 Feb 2;2:247-51. doi: 10.2147/ppa.s3806.
Allergen immunotherapy (IT) is an effective treatment of respiratory allergy, but requires strict rules of performance. This makes compliance particularly relevant, but thus far only a few studies have investigated this issue.
We reviewed all the available articles on compliance and adherence with IT in its different forms of administration, ie, subcutaneous (SCIT), sublingual (SLIT), and local nasal (LNIT).
Early studies, when only SCIT was available, reported a low compliance, ranging from 45% to 60%, but the demanding schedules used, with very frequent injections, accounted for this outcome, as shown by patients' recognition of inconvenience as the major cause of noncompliance. The most recent studies reported a good compliance, estimated in 75% to 90%, to both SCIT and SLIT, inconvenience remaining the major cause of noncompliance, followed by cost of the treatment. The only study addressing LNIT found a very poor compliance (27%), the major cause being the side effects, with repeated nasal reactions to the allergen extract.
Adequate education of patients and optimization of administration schedules, with fine balancing between dose effectiveness and cost, are the factors most likely to achieve further improvement of compliance with IT.
变应原免疫疗法(IT)是治疗呼吸道过敏的一种有效方法,但需要严格的操作规范。这使得依从性尤为重要,但迄今为止只有少数研究探讨过这个问题。
我们检索了所有关于不同给药形式(即皮下注射免疫疗法(SCIT)、舌下含服免疫疗法(SLIT)和局部鼻内免疫疗法(LNIT))的IT依从性和坚持性的可用文章。
早期研究中,当时只有SCIT可用,报告的依从性较低,在45%至60%之间,但所采用的严格时间表,注射非常频繁,导致了这一结果,正如患者认为不便为不依从的主要原因所表明的那样。最近的研究报告称,SCIT和SLIT的依从性都很好,估计在75%至90%之间,不便仍然是不依从的主要原因,其次是治疗费用。唯一一项针对LNIT的研究发现依从性非常差(27%),主要原因是副作用,即对变应原提取物反复出现鼻部反应。
对患者进行充分教育并优化给药时间表,在剂量有效性和成本之间进行精细平衡,是最有可能进一步提高IT依从性的因素。