Harvard School of Public Health, Department of Epidemiology, Boston, USA.
Indian Pediatr. 2009 Nov;46(11):983-9.
Measles remains a major cause of child mortality in India. Measles case fatality ratios (CFRs) vary substantially between countries and even within the same community over time. We present a review of Indian community-based measles CFR studies conducted from 1975 to 2008.
PubMed, Cochrane Libraries, and all WHO databases were searched using a combination of terms. All community-based studies were abstracted into a database.
We identified 25 studies with data on 27 communities. The median CFR was 1.63 per 100 cases (Q1= 0.00 and Q3= 5.06). Studies conducted after 1994 had significantly lower CFRs (P=0.031). Studies in rural settings had significantly higher CFRs compared to urban studies (P=0.015). No differences were found by study design or outbreak/endemic setting.
This review suggests measles CFR may be declining in India. We hypothesize that increased measles vaccination coverage is the main factor contributing to the decline. Widespread vaccination increases both the average age of infection and the proportion of total measles cases previously vaccinated. Vitamin A treatment/supplementation is also likely to have contributed. In order to further reduce measles burden in India, vaccination and vitamin A treatment/supplementation coverage should be increased and a two dose vaccine strategy should be implemented in all areas.
麻疹仍然是印度儿童死亡的主要原因。麻疹病死率(CFR)在国家之间甚至在同一社区随时间变化而有很大差异。我们回顾了 1975 年至 2008 年期间在印度进行的基于社区的麻疹 CFR 研究。
使用组合术语对 PubMed、Cochrane 图书馆和所有世界卫生组织数据库进行了搜索。将所有基于社区的研究都摘要到一个数据库中。
我们确定了 25 项研究,这些研究的数据来自 27 个社区。中位数 CFR 为每 100 例 1.63(Q1=0.00,Q3=5.06)。1994 年后进行的研究 CFR 明显较低(P=0.031)。与城市研究相比,农村地区的研究 CFR 明显较高(P=0.015)。研究设计或暴发/流行环境无差异。
本综述表明印度的麻疹 CFR 可能在下降。我们假设麻疹疫苗接种覆盖率的增加是导致下降的主要因素。广泛的疫苗接种增加了感染的平均年龄和以前接种过麻疹疫苗的总病例比例。维生素 A 治疗/补充也可能有贡献。为了进一步降低印度的麻疹负担,应增加疫苗接种和维生素 A 治疗/补充的覆盖率,并在所有地区实施两剂疫苗策略。