University of California, San Diego, Del Mar, 92014, USA.
Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev. 2009 Dec;18(12):3476-83. doi: 10.1158/1055-9965.EPI-09-0176.
The potential for negative screening to reduce smoking cessation and long-term abstinence is a concern in lung cancer screening. We examine whether consistently negative results during long-term participation in a lung cancer screening program reduce cessation or increase relapse.
Participants (N = 2,078) in the Early Lung Cancer Action Program received annual screenings and periodic smoking behavior surveys over a follow-up period as long as 12 years. Point abstinence and prolonged abstinence were examined among 730 baseline smokers. Relapse was examined among 1,227 former smokers who quit for 1 year or more at enrollment, 121 recent quitters at enrollment, and 155 baseline smokers who quit during follow-up. Abstinence and relapse for participants with consistently negative computerized tomography scan results were compared with those with non-cancer-positive results using stratified Cox models.
Baseline smokers with negative computerized tomography scans had a 28% lower likelihood of achieving point abstinence at one or more follow-up assessments compared with those with positive scans (hazard ratio, 0.72; P < 0.0004), but consistently negative scans were not associated with a lower likelihood of prolonged abstinence. A consistently negative scan was not associated with a higher likelihood of relapse back to smoking for long-term former smokers, recent quitters, or those who quit during follow-up.
We did not detect a lower long-term smoking abstinence or increased relapse over a 6-year period of follow-up among individuals participating in a lung cancer screening program who have a consistently negative screening compared with those with a positive, but noncancer, screening result.
消极筛查可能会降低戒烟和长期戒烟的效果,这是肺癌筛查的一个关注点。我们研究了长期参与肺癌筛查计划期间持续出现阴性结果是否会降低戒烟率或增加复吸率。
早期肺癌行动计划的参与者(N=2078)接受了为期 12 年以上的年度筛查和定期吸烟行为调查。在 730 名基线吸烟者中,检查了点戒烟和长期戒烟情况。在 121 名入组时近期戒烟者、155 名在随访期间戒烟的基线吸烟者以及 155 名在入组时戒烟 1 年或更长时间的前吸烟者中,检查了复吸情况。使用分层 Cox 模型比较了计算机断层扫描结果持续阴性的参与者与非癌症阳性结果的参与者的戒烟和复吸情况。
与扫描阳性者相比,基线扫描阴性的吸烟者在一个或多个随访评估时达到点戒烟的可能性低 28%(危险比,0.72;P<0.0004),但持续阴性扫描与延长戒烟的可能性降低无关。持续阴性扫描与长期前吸烟者、近期戒烟者或随访期间戒烟者复吸的可能性增加无关。
与扫描阳性但非癌症阳性结果的参与者相比,在一项为期 6 年的随访中,参与肺癌筛查计划且持续出现阴性筛查结果的个体并没有出现长期戒烟率降低或复吸率增加的情况。