Department of Entomology, Faculty of Agriculture, Kasetsart University, Bangkok 10900, Thailand.
J Med Entomol. 2009 Nov;46(6):1407-14. doi: 10.1603/033.046.0622.
This study quantified both contact irritancy and noncontact repellency behavioral responses of three strains of Aedes aegypti (L.) (one long-term colony and two F1-F2 generation field-caught strains) to field application rates of DDT (2 g/m2) and alpha-cypermethrin (ACyp) (0.025 g/m2) by using an excito-repellency test chamber. The colony The colony strain (USDA) was completely susceptible to DDT and ACyp. One field strain was collected from Chiang Mai (CM) Province, northern Thailand, and was characterized as tolerant (reduced susceptibility) to DDT and completely susceptible to ACyp. The second field strain, collected from Kanchanaburi (KAN) Province, western Thailand, was highly resistant to DDT but fully susceptible to ACyp. All three strains exhibited marked irritancy to contact with ACyp, with more pronounced escape responses occurring in the two field strains. With DDT, the KAN strain demonstrated the lowest escape response during both contact and noncontact trials, whereas a greater response was seen in trials conducted with CM and USDA strains. With exposure to ACyp, repellency was less profound than irritancy but still resulted in a significant escape response compared with paired controls without insecticide (P < 0.05). DDT elicited both irritancy and repellency responses but comparably greater spatial repellency than ACyp. Findings indicate ACyp functions primarily as a strong contact irritant, whereas DDT functions as a relatively strong noncontact repellent in the strains tested. The higher the degree of physiological resistance to DDT, the greater the apparent suppression of both behavioral avoidance responses. Most importantly, observations using susceptible, tolerant, and resistant Ae. aegypti strains show that behavioral responses that can interrupt human-vector contact still occur regardless of degree of physiological susceptibility to compounds tested.
本研究采用激惹-驱避测试室定量评估了三种埃及伊蚊(Aedes aegypti)品系(一个长期品系和两个 F1-F2 代野外捕获品系)对滴滴涕(DDT,2 g/m2)和α-氯氰菊酯(ACyp,0.025 g/m2)田间使用剂量的接触性激惹和非接触性驱避的行为反应。该实验室品系(USDA)对 DDT 和 ACyp 完全敏感。一个野外品系来自泰国北部清迈省(CM),表现出对 DDT 的耐药性(降低的敏感性)和对 ACyp 的完全敏感性。第二个野外品系来自泰国西部的北碧府(KAN),对 DDT 高度耐药,但对 ACyp 完全敏感。所有三个品系对接触 ACyp 均表现出明显的激惹性,两个野外品系的逃避反应更为明显。用 DDT 进行试验时,KAN 品系在接触和非接触试验中表现出最低的逃避反应,而 CM 和 USDA 品系的试验中则观察到更大的反应。接触 ACyp 时,驱避作用不如激惹作用明显,但与无杀虫剂的配对对照相比,仍导致显著的逃避反应(P < 0.05)。DDT 既引起激惹反应,也引起驱避反应,但与 ACyp 相比,空间驱避作用更强。研究结果表明,ACyp 主要作为一种强烈的接触性激惹剂,而 DDT 在测试的品系中作为一种相对较强的非接触性驱避剂。对 DDT 的生理抗性程度越高,对两种行为回避反应的明显抑制作用就越大。最重要的是,使用敏感、耐药和抗性埃及伊蚊品系的观察结果表明,无论对测试化合物的生理敏感性程度如何,仍会发生可中断人与媒介接触的行为反应。